Aggie Awards
Aggie Awards

2013 Aggie Awards


Article updated Friday, February 21st. Already read about Day One and Day Two?  Skip straight ahead to the final day's presentation!
 



This was supposed to be THE year – the year when all our favourite old-school developers returned to the genre in a blaze of glory.

As it turned out, some of them made it only halfway to the finish line, while others are still heading around the final turn into the home stretch, leaving unlucky 2013 a little thin on high-profile adventures. But as always, there were more than a few games that came out of nowhere to dazzle us and make for another year of hard Aggie decisions. You should know – you got to vote, too!

After all the hemming and hawing and waiting for bribes that never came, at last all the ballots have been cast and counted (and counted again in Florida), and it's time once again to reward the genre’s best offerings of the previous calendar year, both from staff and readers alike.

The beauty of awards is that they encourage healthy debate, and we welcome more of the same this year. Just remember: this is a celebration of success, not the Hunger Games. Whether first place or fifth, all the games here are deserving of recognition and praise, so enjoy yourselves and join us in applauding the talented developers who brought us another great year of gaming.

The awards presentation will run daily from Wednesday through Friday, so check back in each day to find out which games will take home the coveted golden statuettes.  And now, roll on, Aggies!

 



Table of Contents


Day One


Page 1: You are here
Page 2: Best Story
Page 3: Best Writing - Comedy
Page 4: Best Writing - Drama
Page 5: Best Character
Page 6: Best Gameplay
Page 7: Best Concept

 

Day Two (To be posted Thursday, February 20th)


Page 8: Best Setting
Page 9: Best Graphic Design
Page 10: Best Animation
Page 11: Best Music
Page 12: Best Voice Acting
Page 13: Best Sound Effects

 

Day Three (To be posted Friday, February 21st)


Page 14: Best Independent Adventure (Commercial)
Page 15: Best Console/Handheld Adventure (Exclusive)
Page 16: Best Non-Traditional Adventure
Page 17: Best Traditional Adventure
Page 18: Best Adventure of 2013
Page 19: Final Notes

 



First up: Best Story... the envelope, please!

Continued on the next page...


About the Author


Other articles...

Tim Schafer – Double Fine interview

PC Mac PS Vita PS4

Bear With Me review

PC Mac Linux


Comments

Skywalker333 Skywalker333
Feb 19, 2014

Glad to see that the readers gave Cognition a deserving place since AG unfortunately didn’t put it in the finalists in most categories. And I am sure it will continue like this!

*edited to fix misunderstanding Wink

Jackal Jackal
Feb 19, 2014

We didn’t forget it.

Manuel Manuel
Feb 19, 2014

I am glad to se that all readers choices are the same as mine.
I don´t understand the fascination with Gone Home, but I guess it just wasn´t my thing, at least the readers recognized Cognition for it´s story. I am eager to see if the game of the year will be the one I voted for.

Skywalker333 Skywalker333
Feb 19, 2014

i said in most Jackal, not all. No need to go on defense. You have it nominated only in one category: Gameplay.

zane
Feb 19, 2014

Will be interesting to see if gone home gets any reader awards, while it probably gets 5+ from the site.

Jackal Jackal
Feb 19, 2014

It doesn’t matter what you meant, skywalker. We didn’t forget it. It just didn’t beat out other games.

Uninvited Ghost
Feb 19, 2014

Speaking of what people are meaning, I’m sure what you meant to say was, “I assure you we took all the relevant games into consideration.”, but it’s coming out as “Cognition sucks.”

zane
Feb 19, 2014

On cognition: i cant really make a judgement. I havnt played it much beyond the demo. But it was funny that the article suggests it won because of association with jane jensen. Im still trying to figure out why gone home won best story… Their methods for telling a story were interesting and well done for sure… but the story content itself? Extremely cliche, bland, and uneventful. The “normal person meets rebel, they become unlikely friends, they fall in love but society disapproves, they almost break up but instead run away” has been done hundreds of times. This game puts absolutely no twist on that at all. Again, their method was interesting… but that belongs in a category like best concept, not the story itself.

Jackal Jackal
Feb 19, 2014

UG, I guess in a world where not making a top 5 list of the year’s best means something “sucks”, that might be true. But that world isn’t this one. Nothing I said implies that.

And speaking of badly twisting words to mean something different, zane, the article says that SOME of the credit (in fact, just “a little”) for Cognition’s story success goes to Jensen.

zane
Feb 19, 2014

Yeah well, to me that “With all due respect” sounds a lot like “no offense but”, and typically “a little something to do with” doesnt literally mean a little.

zane
Feb 19, 2014

And if it did in fact literally mean “a little”, well then it neglects to tell us what it had ” a lot” to do with Wink Other than it had a “rousing start”. see what i mean?

Uninvited Ghost
Feb 20, 2014

I never implied you forgot about Cognition or even that I’m disagreeing with your assessment of the game. I was just pointing out how bluntly you’re responding to the criticism. I was saying you likely weren’t meaning to be negative about Cognition in response to the criticism, but it’s coming across to me (and likely others) that way.

subbi subbi
Feb 20, 2014

Geezze, is all you folks can do is whine about the fact that some of the editors descriptions in this article are not entirely your cup of tea?
Don’t you see that there’s a little tongue-in-cheek humor in there occasionally?
It’s quite a bit of work to put all of this together, so a little but more appreciation is due here imo!
And beyond: we can all agree that Gone Home won the critic award and Cognition the user vote. You’re free to decide which means more to you.

CroGamer CroGamer
Feb 20, 2014

I am really glad to see Cognition here, but I’m still hoping to see Memoria somewhere.

Dienerstrasse Dienerstrasse
Feb 20, 2014

I agree with subbi. If I were Jackal, I’d get a little tired of having to defend the site’s integrity every single time AG do a countdown like this. As soon as their results don’t match some reader’s personal opinions, there will be bitching about it and AG staff will be called to the question.

Simon_ASA Simon_ASA
Feb 20, 2014

Thanks to the AG team for these results, and I’m sorry that they won’t please everyone : I’m sure it was a lot of work to decide. I find it interesting for a small dev like me to discover what you chose and why, as it’s quite a good summary of the best ideas of the year.

Becky Becky
Feb 20, 2014

The purpose of the awards is to compliment, not criticize. The short write-ups are a way to celebrate the game and provide some context (for instance, mentioning that Jane Jensen was a significant influence) in a way that is entertaining and hopefully not (gasp) boring. So humor is part of the equation. Deconstructing every phrase and guessing that it has an alternate meaning is kind of beside the point.

I’m now wondering how “beside the point” might be deconstructed. Smile

I think the goal is to spark conversation/debate about the games that were released this past year—an awards format is a great way to do that.

hammer
Feb 20, 2014

I’m sorry, but I really thought that Gone Home as an overall game was crap. Of course, that was mostly for other reasons such as technical (crashes) and gameplay (lack of), but the story was just OK. Definitely not the best of the year. There was barely a story. You can sum up the whole story in one paragraph, maybe 2. I don’t see how that can win best story.

No offense, AdventureGamers.

hammer
Feb 20, 2014

Regarding Cognition, I am also surprised that it (deservedly) won the reader’s choice for best story and best dramatic writing, but wasn’t even in the top 5 for the editors. However, As I didn’t yet play any of the editors’ runner-up games that beat out Cognition, maybe they know something that I don’t. Smile

SamuelGordon SamuelGordon
Feb 20, 2014

I love it when my choices don’t win, means i have some gaming to do!:) Swiss Constable Anton Zellner looks really interesting, so i’m gonna play the raven. I haven’t played Tales of two brothers either. 

I like AG’s choices (and the fan’s ofc!) and look forward to day 2!!

Cowboy Bibop
Feb 20, 2014

Well… i do believe that Cognition has been awarded in the past (if i’m not mistaken it won best game in 2012… or at lest was awarded with a few trophies).

So it’s normal that the guys behind Adventure Gamers aren’t higlighting it this year.

I played 1 hour of the firts episode and didn’t amaze me, but still i will give another try as i think i’ll enjoy it as the detective work settles in.

After playing Heavy Rain i was expecting much more from Quantic Dream and Beyond. But well… i value much more the “Adventurers” review and community that its Metacritic score… so i’ll pick it up 2nd hand.

driver8 driver8
Feb 20, 2014

The quote from the article: “With all due respect to the developer’s own talented team of designers, we’ll go out on a limb and suggest that a certain “consultant” named Jane Jensen might have had a little something to do with Cognition fairly comfortably claiming the reader award for top story of the year.”

When I read this, I took it to mean that the strength of the story was thanks to Jane Jensen, not that readers had voted for it more because she was involved than because of the story quality.

Oscar Oscar
Feb 20, 2014

With all the insults being flung at Gone Home, I would suggest that its story was exactly what adventure games needed - simple but extremely potent and emotional. It was refreshing to see so much effort put not into more and more details but making a very basic story richer with everything you find, and it was the only 2013 game (besides maybe Two Brothers) where I wanted to find out what happened above wanting to complete the game.

I’m tired of AGs thinking that endless twists and turns will make a story interesting to me. Rather, it’s more likely to turn me away. Even Deponia, which should have been a humble comedy series, I had trouble following because of the needless (and endless) exposition, which probably only existed to stretch the game out to a trilogy. AGs need to know how to extend a game by deepening it rather than just adding more characters and events.

zane
Feb 20, 2014

^The third deponia really did get carried away in that sense (but i liked it anyway). But really, im not asking for endless twists from gone home, im asking for anything intriguing or thought provoking. The story landed very flat to me. And the attention to detail, and the ability to use the house to tell a story was neat and refreshing. Its just too bad they didnt have more of a story to tell.

Jackal Jackal
Feb 20, 2014

The endless negativity is incredibly annoying, subbi. And time consuming, and utterly pointless.

I mean, apparently calling Phoenix Online a “talented team of designers” is somehow an insult because we dared mentioned their famous story consultant, whom the developers themselves openly credit for her valuable input. I swear, some people go looking for reasons to be offended, even if they have to completely make them up.

What’s even more disappointing is that people are using the Aggies to yet again slag games they don’t like. Like Becky (and the article itself) said earlier, the whole point of this thing is to celebrate games that did great things in the past year. If people can’t do that without pissing all over the choices they disagree with, then maybe it is time to reconsider whether this is even worth doing. I expect better from this crowd.

typ
Feb 21, 2014

I can’t tell you how disappointed I am in fellow video game players’ inability to look past the facade that was Sam’s “simple” story. Even people who liked the game weren’t able to spot that narrative as a honeypot, just one single perspective of a family, something to intrigue that player into exploring the history of the house including how a terrifying event in the father’s childhood rippled through generations and was finally overcome unknowingly by Sam’s rebellion. Every single place you look closer in the household, from the little touches like Sam being a better writer than her father to Lonnie’s loyalty to the army, you will find not only depth but consistency in theme. Was it because they were feminist themes that revolved around patriarchal decay that the average player couldn’t even register their existence? Other mediums often give their audiences enough credit to recognize subtlety, meanwhile here we get condescending comments asking for depth when it is laid plainly in front of you. Fullbright asks players “what if instead of using the ham-fisted storytelling of other games, we placed the players in an environment that was so rich in detail that they could piece together the story themselves through exploration and rumination - could we trust the player to figure out the big picture on their own?” and videogamers responded with a resounding “No.”

subbi subbi
Feb 21, 2014

Well, there is a sizable bunch of people that really do appreciate the Aggies (and the excellent Top100 list, which is even more work to pull off), so please keep doing these. They are nice moments in the year that put the spotlight on a genre that is otherwise pretty much neglected.

So many thanks for that!

CroGamer CroGamer
Feb 21, 2014

I’m really glad that Cognition won the Music Award. I still listen to the soundtrack Smile

Simon_ASA Simon_ASA
Feb 21, 2014

ahah ! I see that ASA didn’t win in the Best Sound Effects category. Honestly this is not a surprise and I didn’t have much hope Smile I’m very happy that the game was nominated previously. Thanks for that, and thanks for the Aggie2013 awards ! I have to admit that I agree globally with your choices and the reader’s choices. Can’t wait to discover the last results tomorrow !

Overmann.ita Overmann.ita
Feb 21, 2014

Richard & Alice deserved more - at least to be mentioned in the best writing for drama category. Also, Face Noir deserved to be mentioned either into the Graphics Design or into the Best Setting category.
My two cents for what they’re worth.

SamuelGordon SamuelGordon
Feb 21, 2014

Please don’t cancel any future aggie awards, i actually enjoy these. 

Day2:

i’m surprised Byond didn’t win best animation (i don’t know a thing about “Lilly Looking Through”, so somethng to check out). Voice acting was obvious, Cognition a close second )

On to day 3!

Skywalker333 Skywalker333
Feb 21, 2014

And Cognition takes the cake from the readers! Nearly half of the categories + best game. Nice to see that so many people liked it Wink

btw, Lily had best animation than Beyond? I haven’t played it yet and i am intrigued by this.

cesarbittar
Feb 21, 2014

I want to thank everyone that brought Cognition up to the top of the Reader’s Awards with 6 awards, including the top prize of the year! We are very humbled at Phoenix online for all of your support, and we are glad you loved our commercial debut so much. You’ve made us all very happy today!

Thank you all. You’ve inspired us to continue thriving and getting better and better at the genre!

Congrats to all the winners!

Cesar Bittar
CEO
Phoenix Online Studios

Dag Dag
Feb 22, 2014

Thanks, Adventure Gamers, for this beautiful writeup. I look forward to the Aggies every year, and, as always, you’ve presented us with a very enjoyable read.

Nibiru
Feb 22, 2014

I agree,Tale of two Sons fantastic story,great caracters and great visual experience.And Cognition as readers choice spot on.Really good.

subbi subbi
Feb 22, 2014

What puzzles me is that Cognition was also in last years AGGIEs, so I guess last year only the first episode was covered and for this years AGGIEs the first episode was probably not taken into account. I think Jackal explained that it depends on whether an episodic game was sold separately as a whole season. The user vote took it as a whole season, including the strong first episode, but should in fact only count the episodes of 2013.
This explains why the critics did not nominate Cognition for most categories.

Jackal Jackal
Feb 22, 2014

Yes, we really shouldn’t have included Cognition last year, and instead just treated the whole game as a 2013 release. But it’s tough getting a handle on dealing with episodic releases, so that was a lesson learned. We didn’t include Broken Age, Broken Sword this year for that reason. Then again, we did include Kentucky Route Zero, which raises the same kinds of problems for next year (like Cognition, it probably won’t get the same weight of consideration the second time, but both benefited from winning staff awards the first year).

cesarbittar
Feb 22, 2014

I agree that with a game with episodic releases, it should be weighed once all episodes have been fully released. It was very hard to judge where Cognition was going with just one episode being released, and in fact, many people were on the fence until ep2 and especially 3 were released, where we could finally show where the story and characters were going. On the other hand, it did help us in terms of us being indie, so it’s always hard to tell.

RockNFknRoll
Feb 23, 2014

I feel like Dream Machine should have gotten at LEAST an honorable mention somewhere. If nothing else, for art design. I really enjoyed that series.

Becky Becky
Feb 23, 2014

I think Dream Machine is a good example of how tricky it can be to decide when to consider an episodic release for the Aggie awards. The game will eventually have six chapters. The first two chapters released in 2010, the third chapter released in 2011 and the fourth in 2013. If you waited until the game was finished to consider it, you might be waiting until 2015.

It’s almost impossible to know exactly how long it will be before many episodic games are completed. (In the case of Dream Machine, since so much is modeled in clay, the process is slow—but other episodic releases also encounter unexpected challenges that slow the process down). And it’s quite difficult to compare pieces of a game to another game that’s finished and whole.

RockNFknRoll
Feb 23, 2014

I hate episodic games a whole lot. I just want to make that clear, thanks.

tsampikos tsampikos
Feb 24, 2014

I don’t understand why the “traditional adventure”  has become a subcategory of this contest. After all the “traditional” adventure is the “definition” of an adventure game and should be the main category (or better to say no category), with everything else beeing a subcategory. The readers awards seem to be far more logical and representative to the adventure gaming spirit that the staff choices.

Jackal Jackal
Feb 24, 2014

Claiming a traditional adventure is the “definition” of adventure is so wrong, it really doesn’t merit explaining why.

Cowboy Bibop
Feb 25, 2014

Jackal WINS.

Sorry Tsampikos, but your definition of Adventure is really short sighted.

Wasn’t Heavy Rain an adventure? And wasn’t it a cool one?

If you’re going to complain about the lack of a mouse cursor, then you might as well be considering Grim Fandango (the best adventure game of all times in my opinion) something else.

adventurer78
Feb 25, 2014

I don’t understand the point of showing runners-up in each category.

I can’t understand why Cognition and Gone Home are considered best story of the year. Last year there weren’t good stories.

Fyshrael
Feb 27, 2014

I mus say that the runners up became a bit of an un-necessary read since it was mostly the same few games in every list…

but posting the runners up is great because it shows that a game you may have discounted, might have a lot more to it… or if you don’t have a huge amount of time for games then it is a nice list of games you should play when you do.

Although i personally think Beyond Two Souls should have gotten a few more awards, I still want to thank AG for these lists, please keep up the good work

Jackal Jackal
Mar 1, 2014

Heaven forbid there should be a variety of games to choose from. If it ain’t 1993 all over again, I guess it’s not an adventure!

Honestly, people.

Jackal Jackal
Mar 2, 2014

I understand that narrow-minded people who only want us to cover the type of games they like are the source of endless whining. That’s about as much as I care about anyone’s personal agendas and arbitrary genre distinctions.

But thanks for your insightful staffing advice, and for your singleminded negativity in an article designed to honour the year’s best games and the designers who made them. Whatever would we all do without contributions like this.

subbi subbi
Mar 2, 2014

Suejak, god forbid you could actually read the Aggies to get some new idea’s on games to play, maybe a game you’d otherwise wouldn’t have picked up.
If you’re only looking for games that feature PnC, inventory puzzles and in an AGS style, then please do go some place else. I’m sure that there are sites that only celebrate games with such narrow definitions and I’m equally sure they could use a few more devoted fans such as yourself, as the majority of us appreciate an evolving genre, albeit in different ways.

DarkEye DarkEye
Mar 2, 2014

(Subbi) If you think that majority of gamers are fascinated by all this non traditional “adventures”, than could you tell me please why both “broken”
games consist of 60+ pages on forum?And yes, I hate games like “the wolf
among us” because that is not even a game let alone adventure.
Jackal, I appreciate all of your hard work on this site(and whole stuff), site
looks awesome.But only issue is that you’re little unfair on the reviews of
“classic adventures”.Reader comes to conclusion that traditional adventures era is over, because those games are sooo boring for Today’s Youth.


Page 1 of 2  1 2 > 
Post a comment

You need to be logged in to post comments. Not a member? Register now!