Adventure Gamers - Forums

Final result

Iznogood, feel free to start a new community playthrough thread for Syberia 2.

11 Syberia 2: Iznogood(leader), TimovieMan, Sefir, SoccerDude, Jabod, mart, rtooney, Becky, Mikekelly, Duck of Doom, diego
10 Shadow of the Comet: Kurufinwe(leader), wilco, Sefir, SoccerDude, mart, Renacimiento, Karlok, chrissie, Duck of Doom, crabapple
9 Timequest: Karlok(leader), Sefir, wilco, TimovieMan, crabapple, Bonsai, Duck of Doom, chrissie, diego
8 J.U.L.I.A. Among the Stars: Iznogood(leader), Sefir, SoccerDude, Jabod, wilco,  Noddy, Becky, harald
7 Hotel Dusk: Mikekelly(leader), Noddy, TimovieMan, Karlok, wilco, SoccerDude, Kurufinwe
7 Gabriel Knight: Sins of the Fathers 20th Anniversary Edition: Intense Degree(leader), chrissie, Lady K, Advie, Mikekelly, millenia, Detective Mosely
6 Atlantis 2: Lady K(leader), Sefir, Kurufinwe, wilco, rtooney, crabapple
4 Broken Sword: Shadow of the Templars: Intense Degree(leader), Kurufinwe, TimovieMan, Noddy
4 Ghost Pirates of Vooju Island: Iznogood(leader), SoccerDude, wilco, Becky
4 The Experiment: Kurufinwe, wilco, Becky, millenia
4 Memento Mori 2: Iznogood(leader), chrissie, millenia, Renacimiento
3 Escape from Monkey Island: TimovieMan(leader), Iznogood, Noddy
3 Alida: Lady K(leader), crabapple, Becky
2 Murder in the Abbey: Sefir(leader), SoccerDude
2 Al Emmo and the Lost Dutchman’s Mine: rtooney, Noddy
1 Danganronpa: Mikekelly(leader)

HEY! Hang on a minute as there was just no time for some of the others that voted for both games to decide as you needed to extend the time a little to allow for those members to see the thread in the event of a tie!

EDIT: I’m sorry, I don’t want to be contentious but in the event of a tie you need to allow more time for voting & this result is not fair as you haven’t allowed more time to wait & see!

chrissie - 13 August 2015 03:21 PM

HEY! Hang on a minute as there was just no time for some of the others that voted for both games to decide as you needed to extend the time a little to allow for those members to see the thread in the event of a tie!

I didn’t decide, it was diego.

Edit: Fair enough, if we don’t want to count diego’s vote, we can leave it to the 4 people on voted for both games to vote.

Well, if I had any inkling to replay Syberia 2 at all you’ve now squashed that idea as the choice is not as democratic as it should have been as you haven’t allowed extra time for the tie for it to be voted on fairly.

Okay I retract diego’s vote as it is 5 minutes late, and in fairness, it does break the rule set in place about all votes needing to be submitted at 12:00 PST.

So the final result stands with a tie:

To break the tie here is how it will happen. There are 4 people who voted for both games:

Sefir
SoccerDude
mart
Duck of Doom

Each of them will choose Syberia 2 or Shadow of the Comet, and the game with most votes will win.

Oh, ffs people!

Alright, I formally rescind my vote for Shadow of the Comet and my offer to lead the playthrough.

Syberia 2 wins.

The end.

Kurufinwe - 13 August 2015 03:40 PM

Oh, ffs people!

Alright, I formally rescind my vote for Shadow of the Comet and my offer to lead the playthrough.

Syberia 2 wins.

The end.

Please don’t do that, it will just add fuel to the fire. Let’s stick with the plan.

I’ll go first:

I pick Syberia 2, because it has been a runner up so many times before, that I believe it finally deserves its chance in the limelight.

Current result:

Syberia 2: 1 (SoccerDude)
Shadow of the Comet: 0

Sefir, mart, and Duck of Doom, your turn please

Normally it might have been a difficult choice. Now I’m all in for Syberia 2 though and that’s easily where my vote goes. That’s mainly because it was voted by one person more than the SotC playthrough => more people are willing to participate in a Syberia 2 AGCP.

I’m gonna go with Syberia 2 as well.
Both because it’s been in the running so many times lately and I’m sure Shadow of the Comet will have its time, now that it’s on GOG- but mainly because I already own Syberia 2

The voters who voted on both games (SoccerDude, Sefir, Duck of Doom, mart), voted in the majority for Syberia 2.

Syberia 2: 3 (SoccerDude, Sefir, Duck of Doom)
Shadow of the Comet: 0

Final result

Iznogood, feel free to start a new community playthrough thread for Syberia 2.

Thanks SoccerDude for leading the voting & putting up with a few adversities from members but I do now feel that Syberia 2 won fairly!