Gabriel Knight 3 review

The Good:
  • Several interesting narratives that all interconnect with a back-story so huge it takes into account the Catholic Church
  • The Cathars
  • The Templars
  • The Priory of Sion
  • Jesus Christ and the history of Mary Magdalen. Continues the strong characterization of the first two games
  • Finally revealing the beginnings of the Schattenjagers. Detailed 3-D graphics give a sense of reality to the game's setting. Contains "Le Serpent Rouge"
  • Possibly one of the best puzzles ever made
The Bad:
  • Contains some illogical/outright silly puzzles. The back-story is so huge
  • The game takes a "tell don't show" cast by the end. The linear "time block" design can be frustrating due to the posibility of missing story elements and uncued actions required to complete them. The endgame contains action sequences and puzzle elements that can be frustrating. Blocky 3-D character models
Our Verdict: An incredible, audacious attempt that doesn't quite live up to its goals. Easily one of the most complex stories ever told in a computer game. Highly recommended as both the continuation of a great series and on the strength of its high points.

In January of 1982, a book entitled "Holy Blood, Holy Grail" was published. Challenging that the traditional, accepted view of the life of Christ was incomplete, the authors plotted a strange path connecting the mystery of a hidden treasure in the small French village of Rennes-le-Chateau to the history of the Cathars, the Templars, and the Priory of Sion. The book caused no small amount of controversy amongst Christians, especially considering that the book implied a deliberate conspiracy on the part of the Catholic Church to hide or recast certain portions of the messiah's story, most particularly the role of Mary Magdalene.

Springboarding off ideas planted in the storyline of The Beast Within regarding the famous "Black Madonnas" of Europe, the final episode of the Gabriel Knight Mysteries takes the threads of the Rennes-le-Chateau story and weaves a tale of bloodlines and those who would manipulate them for their own ends. Blood of the Sacred, Blood of the Damned's attempt to encompass 2000 years of recorded history into its game play is both its glory and its failing.

The story begins some months after the events of The Beast Within. Gabriel and Grace have recovered from their harrowing adventures and are finally beginning to act as true, equal partners. They are invited to a seemingly innocent weekend at the home of Prince James, the current Stuart heir. It is soon revealed, however, that the Prince's intentions are all business. He knows Gabriel's family history and, as a relation to the Wittlesbach dynasty, of the lost Wagner opera. He has a proposition for them. He has need of a Schattenjager.

The Stuart family, it seems, is victim to a certain strange anemia, one for which medical science has no explanation. Nor is there any explanation for the strange holes that appear in the victim's neck. Prince Stuart is terrified that those responsible, the "night visitors", will come for his infant child Charles next.

The case almost immediately starts off on the wrong foot. Before the game even begins, Charles is kidnapped right under Gabriel's nose. Giving chase, he's led to a train by the two night visitors before being knocked out. On awakening, he finds that he's arrived near the village of Rennes-le-Chateau.

The story follows Gabriel and Grace as they search for Charles and the men who captured him. In the village, Gabriel finds a group of treasure hunters, all of whom seem to have something to hide. As he sneaks into their midst, searching for the lost child, Grace begins to slowly uncover a mystery that has been buried since the days of the Crucifixion, one hidden through the times of the Templars, the Cathars, and the Visigoths to the modern day. As they both continue to dig, both literally and metaphorically, they soon realize that everyone -- even the man who originally hired them -- has a secret agenda.

The game play takes place over three days, the shortest of any game in the series but still perhaps the longest and most complex of the trilogy. Each day is broken up into "time blocks" which can range from two to four hours apiece. While each block will end only when certain conditions are reached (much like the Days and Chapters of the previous entries), there are also optional events which can only be viewed if the player is in the right place at the right time.

While this design seems a good compromise, it can also be frustrating. Sometimes the actions required to complete a time block will be unclear -- especially during the first day when the player does not have access to the game's "hint" function, which informs players of what locations still require events to complete the time block. Also, since most of the game's locations contain multiple sub-locations (most particularly the village itself), it can be difficult to pinpoint precisely where to go next and the game play devolves into blindly visiting everywhere and re-examining everything.

Due to this design, several important subplots in the game are easy to miss. While not necessary to complete the game, players who wish to make sure they see everything will, again, simply have to revisit all available areas in case something new is available.

Blood utilizes an interface that seems a combination of the previous two games. Set in full 3-D, the player moves an imaginary "camera" around the scene rather than directly controlling Gabriel or Grace. Hotspots can be clicked, as in Beast, but upon doing so a series of iconic options becomes available, much like those found in Sins of the Fathers. Thus, clicking on a lamp might give access to the options to examine it, turn it on or off, move it, and so on. The combination combines the strength of both previous interfaces, giving the user quite a bit of control while still remaining straightforward and simple.

The 3-D locations set in and around Rennes-le-Chateau are lovingly implemented, especially the village's church. While the textures are sometimes muddied, there's a wonderful attention to detail in the design. Unfortunately, the sheer scope can also be overwhelming, and scanning over an entire 3-D field for hotspots can give new meaning to the phrase "pixel hunting".

The character models don't work as well as the location models, generally having a clunky feel. This especially comes to the fore in the case of an optional puzzle in which the player must watch a complex handshake played out and then later repeat it. The roughly done hand models end up making this sequence much more complicated than necessary. However, all of the characters do have a unique look and all of their dialogue is lip-synched well.

Tim Curry returns as the voice of Gabriel and his interpretation is as over-the-top as ever. The rest of the cast is generally good, with new voice actors filling in the roles of Grace and Mosley, who reappears after an extended absence in The Beast Within.

Musically, Blood is both the most complex of the series as well as the best implemented. The audio track is technically excellent, utilizing themes that have appeared throughout the series. Also, several sequences are scripted with the music in mind, with wonderful results. Particularly memorable is Grace's explorations of Chateau de Seres during Day Two, which uses a single theme which becomes more complex (and menacing) the further her investigations take her.

The puzzle design varies wildly. Late in Day Two, Grace learns of "Le Serpent Rouge", a pamphlet connected to the Rennes-le-Chateau mystery. Much of the game play story's later part involves solving a series of riddles embedded in its text with the help of SYDNEY, a computer system Grace designed. The entire sequence represents perhaps the best puzzle design ever to appear in an adventure game. SYDNEY is used to analyze diagrams and maps, translate passages from Latin and other languages, and perform cryptographic and anagrammatic functions, all towards the end of solving a fascinating over-arching enigma. Diametrically opposed to "Le Serpent Rouge" is a series of puzzles Gabriel must solve during Day One that involve Mosley and accessing a motorcycle that borders on the absurd. Illogical and downright silly, these puzzles are far from Jensen's best work.

The rest of the game falls somewhere in between. Much of Gabriel's story involves the treasure hunters and, as always, his approach to investigation is something less than legal. Still, it's great fun wandering around the well-implemented hotel, breaking into rooms and rummaging through other people's belongings. Much of Grace's game play is taken up in the aforementioned "Serpent", though earlier there are some interesting segments touring around the valley, learning of its history.

In the end, Blood's storyline seems much more cerebral and, oddly, relaxed than its predecessors. Even though this case is just as dire as previous ones (a kidnapping rather than a murder), the tension involved in finding Charles takes a back seat until almost the end of the game.

In some ways, it seems as if Jensen simply had too much story to handle in three days of game play. Much of the back-story involving the valley's history and the conspiracy is handled via conversations between Gabriel and Grace rather than actual investigative game play. Worse yet, the final series of revelations are handled via a narrative cutscene.

Still, the story Blood of the Sacred, Blood of the Damned attempts to tell is epic in every sense of the word. Spanning centuries, its final resolution ties the various disparate threads of the valley's history, the treasure hunters, the "night visitors" and even the Schattenjagers themselves together into a cohesive and believable whole. The game's final cutscene is a wonderful work of art, and left me sad that a true conclusion to the series will never be reached.

While its design contains some serious issues, Blood is ultimately a success. Its highs far outnumber and outweigh its lows. From the perspective of a game, it contains one of the best designed puzzles in adventure gaming history. From the perspective of narrative, it is one of the most ambitious productions ever attempted. While it may not always reach the heights it targets, the final Gabriel Knight Mystery is a vast and impressive example of the art of adventure games.

What our readers think of Gabriel Knight 3

Posted by kdon27 on Jul 6, 2013

Perfection in 3 CDs

When I came to GK3 I was new to the adventure gaming genre. But there is something about it that has stuck in my head as the best adventure I have ever had in a game. Despite playing games like The Longest Journey, Still Life, Discworld Noir etc... there is...

Posted by emric on May 31, 2012

a highly satisfying adventure spoilt only by ugly 3D presentation

it's a complex, intelligent and immersive story that is expertly told and structured by the amazing Jane Jensen. The very beginning was just a touch slow, but thereafter just kept getting better and better until the amazing climax. Thankfully, Tim Curry is...

Posted by Intense Degree on May 22, 2012

Truly great game despite some problems

This game has come under some criticism due to the “interesting” 3D graphics and one infamous puzzle amongst other things. Also the control mechanism is not to everybody’s taste. It was brave to try something new here but it was quite hard to get used...

All reviews Post review

Adventure games by Sierra On-Line

Gabriel Knight (Series)

Gabriel Knight (Series) 1999

Welcome to the remote French village of Rennes-le-Chateau.

» View all games in this series
Quest for Glory (Series)

Quest for Glory (Series) 1998

The Council of Silmaria has set before you the seven deadly Rites of Rulership.

» View all games in this series
King’s Quest (Series)

King’s Quest (Series) 1998

When the Mask of Eternity, the symbol of order in a chaotic universe, was shattered by a powerful evil, the kingdom of Daventry was beset by a terrible curse.

» View all games in this series
Shivers (Series)

Shivers (Series) 1997

I’m convinced that someone or some thing is after me.

» View all games in this series
Phantasmagoria (Series)

Phantasmagoria (Series) 1996

Curtis Craig is a quiet young man.

» View all games in this series
Leisure Suit Larry (Series)

Leisure Suit Larry (Series) 1996

Will Larry hit bottom? Or dock his little dinghy? Drop a world-class lounge lizard onto a cruise ship filled with gorgeous women and what do you get? Side-splitting slapstick? A bawdy bevy of beauties? The Lust Boat?.

» View all games in this series

Lighthouse: The Dark Being  1996

Pass through a shimmering portal into a world teeming with invention, discovery.

Space Quest (Series)

Space Quest (Series) 1995

Fight grime and battle evil adversaries with Roger as he joins farces with video games, TV and sci-fi movies, past and present – in his wildest adventure ever.

» View all games in this series

Torin’s Passage  1995

I thought I had silenced them all.

Sierra Discovery Series (Series)

Sierra Discovery Series (Series) 1993

Lost Secret of the Rainforest is a trek through lush jungles, mysterious caverns, and ancient ruins atop craccy, mist-covered peaks, requiring you to defeat real-life dangers threatening the rainforests of South America.

» View all games in this series
Police Quest (Series)

Police Quest (Series) 1993

Someone’s on a killing spree, and it’s up to you to solve a string of seemingly random murders.

» View all games in this series

Freddy Pharkas Frontier Pharmacist  1993

Return with us now to those thrilling days of yesteryear… when men were men, women were women, and sheep were scared! The year is 1888; the setting, post-Gold Rush California.

Pepper’s Adventures in Time  1993

Ride the wild time machine into American history with Pepper’s Adventures in Time! .

Laura Bow mysteries (Series)

Laura Bow mysteries (Series) 1992

Laura Bow, intrepid heroine of The Colonel’s Bequest, is back! This time she’s trapped in a huge, imposing museum in the dead of night, surrounded by socialites, miscreants, thieves… and a cold, relentless murderer.

» View all games in this series
Mixed-Up (Series)

Mixed-Up (Series) 1991

Sierra combines Roberta Williams’s master storytelling with the classic rhymes of Mother Goose to create a children’s adventure game so simple that once you start the game, even a young child can take over.

» View all games in this series
Conquests (Series)

Conquests (Series) 1991

The gauntlet has been dropped.

» View all games in this series

Codename: ICEMAN  1989

Oil shortages, international politics and radical terrorists form the backdrop for a powerful story of world crisis, superpower conflict and high tech escapades.

Gold Rush! (Series)

Gold Rush! (Series) 1988

The gold rush is on! Sell your land, pack your bags, and grab the next ride out, because fortune lies just 2,500 miles away.

» View all games in this series

The Black Cauldron  1986

Find the Black Cauldron and defeat the forces of the wicked Horned King by destroying the cauldron’s magical powers, removing it forever as a threat to humankind.

» Full game details

The Dark Crystal  1983

In a faraway world, an event of cosmic importance is about to occur: a Great Conjunction of the planet’s Three Suns.

» Full game details

Mystery House  1980

As you near the front yard of the large, old Victorian house, you feel an unexplainable tension.