Photographs review

The Good:
  • Character stories are compelling
  • Final choice is appropriately weighty
  • Puzzle segments help build anticipation
  • Cute pixel artwork juxtaposes nicely with dark subject matter
The Bad:
  • Use of certain game mechanics isn’t as clear or straightforward as it should be
  • Lack of free-save ability prevents seeing alternate outcomes
  • Puzzles aren’t integrated into the stories
Photographs review
Photographs review
The Good:
  • Character stories are compelling
  • Final choice is appropriately weighty
  • Puzzle segments help build anticipation
  • Cute pixel artwork juxtaposes nicely with dark subject matter
The Bad:
  • Use of certain game mechanics isn’t as clear or straightforward as it should be
  • Lack of free-save ability prevents seeing alternate outcomes
  • Puzzles aren’t integrated into the stories
Our Verdict:

Essentially five short games in one, Photographs presents a series of dark, disturbing, and above all compelling tales of woe interspersed with their own diverting puzzle minigames ranging from easy to challenging.

What's your verdict?
Log in or Register to post ratings.

When it comes to game ratings, “mature” often tends to mean the very opposite of what it should, referring to scary games, gruesome games, foul language, nudity and the like. Yet there’s a big difference between “age appropriate” and actually “mature”, with very few games really tackling dark subject matter in an intelligent, thoughtful, adult way. With its colourful retro-style graphics and soft music box-like tunes, I came into EightyEight Games’s Photographs expecting a cute if perhaps melancholy experience, and was therefore totally unprepared for what followed. Interspersed with a series of related minigames of varying difficulty and satisfaction, its five separate tales are not fun in the conventional sense, but nor are they meant to be. Instead they’re genuinely complex character studies that are difficult to watch (and participate in), and yet impossible to look away from. I hesitate to call the game enjoyable for fear of being branded some sort of sadist, but I don’t know what other term to use for these highly compelling, deeply emotional narratives.

The first of five largely standalone stories concerns a grandfatherly alchemist caring for a young girl. The initial puzzle segment introduces the basics that will continue throughout this one particular tale. Upon completing this challenge, the game presents a Polaroid photograph from the life of the alchemist and girl, with the alchemist himself narrating their story. Following this brief vignette, the photo is dismissed and the alchemist’s home is displayed. As you progress, various elements of the home either pop in or out, including books, furniture, possessions, other people, and even additional floors on the building itself. Once the latest round of changes has occurred, a short label appears like “potions for sale”. Holding the left mouse button down then zooms in on the house, where you must drag the camera viewfinder around in order to find the area that matches the label. In the above example, hovering the cursor over a table of potions will cause the game to take a picture of them, which then launches you into the next minigame sequence.

This puzzle-photograph-home pattern is repeated throughout not only the alchemist’s tale, but the other four as well as they are unlocked in sequence. Each of the five stories features its own completely different setting, characters, narrative and respective minigame, presented one after the other with no option to select which character to follow. The alchemist’s tale starts with he and his young ward living an idyllic life in the countryside with what appears to be a fairly modern city in the distance. While everything starts bright and sunny, all that changes when the little girl contracts a rare disease. The alchemist works night and day to find a cure…and succeeds! For a time, at any rate. Photographs is not a game with the term “happy ending” in its vocabulary, so complications ensue, seriously impacting the young girl’s fate and her relationship to the old man. Watching the girl’s condition worsen through the series of still photos certainly pulls at the heartstrings, and the old man blames himself, whether that guilt is justified or not.

The second story is about a young woman who excels at diving. As we watch a small girl grow into adulthood and become a role model, her drama takes place at the local swimming pool, with higher diving boards and more spectators appearing over time. This too starts off cheerfully, with the protagonist competing only for the love of diving, but in short order it also turns dark as she falls behind and begins dragging her team down. To rectify the situation, she makes questionable decisions until hers becomes a tale of woe as well. Of all the stories, this is the one that could have been the most preachy or judgmental, but it is handled with a light touch and nuance that makes it easy to empathize with the young lady and appreciate the storytelling.

Third up is the tale of an aboriginal man who welcomes white settlers to his land. Appropriately, the backdrop here is an old west landscape framed by rocky badlands. While the two groups initially get along, eventually the settlers claim more and more of the land and there is less food for the aboriginals, leading to inevitable conflict and ultimately the imprisonment of the narrator’s people. Horrified by the situation, the narrator goes to work for the settlers as a compassionate jailer, but can’t prevent the state of affairs from degenerating. As I’d come to expect by this point, the story gets very dark by the end, but what I had not expected was how gruesome it would become. This is easily the goriest tale of the bunch, though the worst horrors are left to the imagination, heightening the tension and making the outcome seem that much more grisly.

The fourth act follows a third generation journalist whose grandfather started a newspaper based on providing uplifting stories. As time goes by the man finds that good news does not sell, so when the paper begins to crumble around him, he decides to start publishing only scandalous news. This story is set in a bustling metropolis office, evolving over time from typewriters through retro printing presses and into the modern computer age. As the reported news gets worse and worse, circulation grows higher and higher than ever before. Unlike the other characters, whose fates worsen through circumstance or misguided bad choices, the journalist embraces this dark path and all the success it entails. Even so, the narrative is conveyed in such a way that it’s possible to see how the man loses his way, step by step, and understand his reasons. Of course, his ruthlessness leaves a great deal of misery in his wake, and it’s only a matter of time before it catches up to him.

The final tale in Photographs takes a turn for the fantastic by following a preventer – an elemental witch with the ability to look into the future and see tragedies before they happen. Able to teleport to the sites of impending disasters, she uses her gifts to work unseen in saving the lives of ordinary people. Unfortunately, the witch looks into the future and sees tragedy in her own life, caused by someone she must later save to fulfill her duties as a preventer. Naturally, things only worsen for her from there. Of the five stories in the game, this is the one that most made me ponder stion its moral implications, and therefore seemed like the strongest of all.

After completing all five tales, the main character from each is brought on-screen. Here you play the hand of fate with the ability to give one – but only one – a chance to change their story. While this feels like an appropriately significant and weighty choice, Photographs makes it more technically difficult than it needs to be. Rather than simply allowing a direct selection, pairs of characters are brought up one at a time with a slider placed between them that must be dragged towards one or the other. However, the slider continually works against you, pulling slowly back towards the center. I found I did not have enough physical desk space to drag the slider in a single mouse movement. I had to pick up the mouse and reposition it two or three times, and re-grab the slowly back-drifting slider to continue. Matters are then compounded by the fact that as the slider draws close to one side or the other, the character on the opposite side starts pleading their case. This displays a speech bubble that caused my mouse hold to be broken. The slider would then move towards center again, requiring yet another retrieval to resume pulling before all progress was lost.

Photographs incorporates a progressive autosave that kicks in after solving each minigame. While this is fine for the majority of the game, I found myself wishing for a manual save option for the second chance decision. Once a choice is made on which character gets a reprieve, that person gets three additional puzzles of their usual type. Playing through the new minigames records your progress beyond the decision point, so that it cannot be restored without replaying the game entirely. I was able to drop out, track down the progress files myself and back them up so I could reload at the appropriate point to give each of the five characters a try without resorting to a complete replay, but really this shouldn’t have been necessary. Between playing through the game once in its entirety and using my save backup “cheat”, all told I spent four hours to experience each of the different endings on offer.

Regardless of who gets a second chance, each ending is shown as a series of still pictures depicting how the new version of the story turns out while the credits run. I felt only two of the characters really got good endings, with the others being just as much of a downer as the original endings, if not more so. Even the good ones aren’t really all that uplifting, as I couldn’t help but feel that I had condemned or abandoned the other four characters to some unknown fate. Of course, the fact that such emotions where evoked in me means that the scenario was doing something profoundly right. I really appreciated that the game didn’t go for “magic bullet” fixes, as that would have cheapened the whole experience.

The narrative element is definitely where Photographs truly excels, but the stories themselves are all completely non-interactive beyond taking pictures of the different scenes where each tale is set. The only notably interactive bits are the minigames paired with each character. While they’re not bad, on their own they’re not much different than what you’d find in a casual mobile app.

The alchemist’s minigames are comprised of a series of movement challenges. A grid is presented with the alchemist and the little girl represented by icons of their faces. These must be guided to their respective homes elsewhere on the game map. Moving the characters is done simply by clicking and dragging either horizontally or vertically across the grid. The two characters then move as far in the indicated direction as possible, stopping only if they hit the edge of the map or some other obstruction.

Continued on the next page...


content continues below

What our readers think of Photographs

No reader reviews yet... Why don't you share your review?

Post review
review