Gabriel Knight 2: The Beast Within review

The Good:
  • A fascinating story of temptation and redemption which further develops the characters and themes started in the series' first episode
  • Told against the backdrop of the life and death of King Ludwig II of Bavaria. Great gameplay in two modes -- modern mystery investigation
  • And historical research
The Bad:
  • New "one click" interface a little too simplistic
  • Some strangely illogical puzzles
  • Uncued actions sometimes required to complete a chapter
  • A frustrating timed sequence in the endgame
Our Verdict: A wonderful follow-up to Sins of the Fathers. One of the few computer games to actually involve personal, meaningful growth in a player-character. Easily one of the best Full Motion Video games ever made.

In the mid-nineties, the big buzzword in the computer gaming industry was "Interactive Movies." Hollywood had invaded gaming, and production companies now had to worry about blue-screens and actors as much as puzzles and gameplay.

Unfortunately, very few good, memorable games came out of this period. While in theory Full Motion Video sounded like a good idea, in practice, the emphasis ended up being much more on "movie" than "interactive." It was found to be too expensive and complicated to film actors performing every single action possible within the constraints of a game. With the advent of 3D technology, FMV fell to the sidelines.

When it was announced that the second episode of the Gabriel Knight mysteries would be using video, I and many other gaming enthusiasts were disappointed. This combined with the fact that none of the voice actors from the first game would be reprising their roles led to worries that much of the charm and continuity of the first game would be lost.

We needn't have worried, though. Gabriel Knight: The Beast Within is a wonderfully complex and engaging piece of gaming history -- one of the few Full Motion Video games whose game play and storyline match those of its 2D predecessors.

The story follows Grace and Gabriel as they travel to Germany to solve a series of murders that have been attributed to escaped zoo wolves. Gabriel, ensconced in his family's seat in Rittersberg, is futilely trying to duplicate the success of his first novel, based on his previous adventures. His attempts are interrupted by locals who know of the Schaatenjagers and their purpose. Investigating the murder of a small girl leads him to a group of men who indulge in their primal natures, and Gabriel disconcertingly finds himself a place among them.

Meanwhile, tired of being left on the sidelines, Grace begins to work on the case on her own initiative -- learning of Rittersberg's history and the story of one of Gabriel's ancestors who faced a creature which called itself The Black Wolf. Digging further leads her to several important historical sites as she learns the final fate of King Ludwig II of Bavaria and the history of Wagner's missing opera. As the story continues, both Grace and Gabriel face their own temptations and trials. Grace will have to fight her way free of Ludwig's romantic world to save Gabriel as he faces his own animalistic, selfish nature.

The sheer sense of history the game gives is difficult to describe. Much of the story's background is based in truth. Real events from Ludwig's life, his agony in his own perceived sinfulness, his relationship with Wagner, and his naive inability to understand the disappointing world around him are combined with Jensen's imagination to produce a fascinating tale of damnation and redemption which parallels Gabriel's own. Several portions of the game take place in real locations, such as Ludwig's castle of Neuschwandstein.

The acting is generally excellent, with Dean Erickson's portrayal of Gabriel being an interesting (and much welcomed) reinterpretation of the role. Yes, Gabriel is still arrogant, selfish and pig-headed, but Erickson's take on the character and his accent aren't quite as over-the-top as Curry's. Joanne Takahashi plays the role of Grace admirably, although early in the game her character's anger comes off as a bit shrill. Both actors manage to capture the changes their characters experience in the course of the game as both of them are forcibly tested in the fires of the challenges facing them.

The production values are high, with several scenes based on digitalized photographs of real German locations. The music continues the series' use of lietmotif and contains some inside musical jokes. The "Gabriel" theme returns accompanied by a haunting new one for Ludwig's scenes. The game also contains a variation of the "police" theme and a sequence where different versions of "When the Saints Go Marching In" are played (as in the first game's Jackson Square location).

The interface is a radical change from the previous installment. Rather than a menu of icons representing various actions the player can take, the player is presented with a single "pointer." Hotspots are highlighted as the cursor is moved over the screen, and clicking performs an action. Unfortunately, this simplified interface proves to be sometimes confusing as it's not entirely clear what action will occur. Often, either Grace or Gabriel would open or take an object when I merely meant to examine it. The inventory interface also takes some getting used to. Rather than choosing an action and then an object to apply it to -- as in previous Sierra adventures -- the order is reversed. Once chosen, objects can be examined, or used on other objects or hotspots in the given scene.

Conversation is again important, as Gabriel and Grace ask questions of the various people they meet. The game pauses on a close-up of the individual and a series of available choices are displayed. However, this interface is also simplified in that topics vanish as they're asked and cannot be returned to. This appears to be an understandable attempt to cut down on the possible number of dialogue sequences that would have to be filmed.

The gameplay follows much the same pattern as that of the first -- Gabriel is presented with a mystery and begins to solve it. There's some interesting amateur forensic work involved, as well as Gabriel's well-known "the end justifies the means" approach to dealing with the police and his suspects.

An added dimension to the game is the ability to play as Grace. Left behind and unable to get in contact with Gabriel (precisely how he likes it), Grace begins to follow the thread of a mystery hidden in Rittersberg's history. Her portions of the game are also investigative, but more likely you'll be digging through museums and books rather than directly questioning suspects.

While many of the puzzles follow the high quality started in the first episode, some are unfortunately uncued and illogical. One of the worst of these involves a cuckoo clock used in an unusual way towards an uncertain end. Also, sometimes actions that don't follow naturally from the storyline will be required to complete a chapter. Grace's sections in the later chapters involve wandering through two museums and a castle. The game will not continue until all of the important hotspots have been examined. This brings the narrative to a crashing halt and it can be incredibly frustrating to have to completely search all three locations to find the one thing necessary to continue the game.

Still, the remaining puzzles are excellent. One of the most difficult (solved by Grace in Chapter Four) requires both an excellent memory of various disparate clues and a certain level of intuition to solve.

The two threads of narrative eventually converge towards a climactic ending in the bowels of an opera house. Unfortunately, the final sequence of actions is both timed and only solveable by trial and error. The combination of the two can be incredibly frustrating, as there's no way for the player to know if a series of actions failed because it was incorrect, or simply mistimed.

By the end of the story, Gabriel and Grace find that they have been profoundly changed by their experiences -- an unusual quality for a computer game. While containing moments of comedy, the entire game is permeated by a quality of sadness, most acutely found in the form of Ludwig himself.

The Beast Within is an incredible achievement. While not flawless, any problems with the game are easily outshined by the wonderful storyline, deep background, and excellent puzzle design. I highly recommend it to any adventure gamer as an shining example of what could be accomplished with Full Motion Video, as well as a classic gameplay experience.


What our readers think of Gabriel Knight 2: The Beast Within


Posted by Antrax on Nov 20, 2013

A good plot can make up for a lot


I was blown away by The Beast Within when it first came out. Returning to it today, its faults are more obvious, but it's still a highly recommended game despite the issues. The video quality still holds up - videos are blocky but clear and the production...

Posted by Niclas on Aug 23, 2012
I must say that I missed to play this game when it was released in the 90's. I only played GK1 and GK3. I just skipped all of the FMV titles out there. I just recently finished the Beast within and I must say it is one of the BEST adventure games that I have...

Posted by emric on May 31, 2012

FMV & overall poor visual presentation spoils an otherwise amazing sequel


Jane Jensen has once again done a brilliant job with story & pacing & characters! the whole premise kept me thoroughly intrigued and engrossed! however various presentation and design issues were such a problem for me that, unfortunately, it seriously...

review

Adventure games by Sierra On-Line

Gabriel Knight (Series)

Gabriel Knight (Series) 1999

Welcome to the remote French village of Rennes-le-Chateau.

» View all games in this series
Quest for Glory (Series)

Quest for Glory (Series) 1998

The Council of Silmaria has set before you the seven deadly Rites of Rulership.

» View all games in this series
Shivers (Series)

Shivers (Series) 1997

I’m convinced that someone or some thing is after me.

» View all games in this series
Phantasmagoria (Series)

Phantasmagoria (Series) 1996

Curtis Craig is a quiet young man.

» View all games in this series
Leisure Suit Larry (Series)

Leisure Suit Larry (Series) 1996

Will Larry hit bottom? Or dock his little dinghy? Drop a world-class lounge lizard onto a cruise ship filled with gorgeous women and what do you get? Side-splitting slapstick? A bawdy bevy of beauties? The Lust Boat?.

» View all games in this series

Lighthouse: The Dark Being  1996

Pass through a shimmering portal into a world teeming with invention, discovery.

Space Quest (Series)

Space Quest (Series) 1995

Fight grime and battle evil adversaries with Roger as he joins farces with video games, TV and sci-fi movies, past and present – in his wildest adventure ever.

» View all games in this series

Torin’s Passage  1995

I thought I had silenced them all.

King’s Quest (Series)

King’s Quest (Series) 1994

Princess Rosella is swept off to the lands of Eldritch by a magical whirlpool, after which her mother, Queen Valanice, jumps in to rescue her wayward daughter.

» View all games in this series
Sierra Discovery Series (Series)

Sierra Discovery Series (Series) 1993

Lost Secret of the Rainforest is a trek through lush jungles, mysterious caverns, and ancient ruins atop craccy, mist-covered peaks, requiring you to defeat real-life dangers threatening the rainforests of South America.

» View all games in this series
Police Quest (Series)

Police Quest (Series) 1993

Someone’s on a killing spree, and it’s up to you to solve a string of seemingly random murders.

» View all games in this series

Freddy Pharkas Frontier Pharmacist  1993

Return with us now to those thrilling days of yesteryear… when men were men, women were women, and sheep were scared! The year is 1888; the setting, post-Gold Rush California.

Pepper’s Adventures in Time  1993

Ride the wild time machine into American history with Pepper’s Adventures in Time! .

Laura Bow mysteries (Series)

Laura Bow mysteries (Series) 1992

Laura Bow, intrepid heroine of The Colonel’s Bequest, is back! This time she’s trapped in a huge, imposing museum in the dead of night, surrounded by socialites, miscreants, thieves… and a cold, relentless murderer.

» View all games in this series
Mixed-Up (Series)

Mixed-Up (Series) 1991

The mischievous Bookend has mixed up the pieces of five of the world’s most famous fairy tales.

» View all games in this series
Conquests (Series)

Conquests (Series) 1991

The gauntlet has been dropped.

» View all games in this series

Codename: ICEMAN  1989

Oil shortages, international politics and radical terrorists form the backdrop for a powerful story of world crisis, superpower conflict and high tech escapades.

Gold Rush! (Series)

Gold Rush! (Series) 1988

The gold rush is on! Sell your land, pack your bags, and grab the next ride out, because fortune lies just 2,500 miles away.

» View all games in this series

The Black Cauldron  1986

Find the Black Cauldron and defeat the forces of the wicked Horned King by destroying the cauldron’s magical powers, removing it forever as a threat to humankind.

» Full game details

The Dark Crystal  1983

In a faraway world, an event of cosmic importance is about to occur: a Great Conjunction of the planet’s Three Suns.

» Full game details

Mystery House  1980

As you near the front yard of the large, old Victorian house, you feel an unexplainable tension.