Adventure Gamers - Forums
You are here: Home → Forum Home → Gaming → Adventure → Thread
Post Marker Legend:
-
New posts -
No new posts
Currently online
[Archived] The Casual Playthrough Voting Thread
What if there’s someone who didn’t vote for either of them? Maybe they should get a tie-breaker vote, too. And if it’s still a tie? Then let our fearless leader (Tim) decide.
These days I go everywhere with a carpetbag containing a crowbar, a flashlight, a screwdriver, an oilcan, a ladder, a zipper tab, and a chihuahua.
Vote total as of August 23 (Last post for the day)
6 Surface: The Noise She Couldn’t Make chrissie (leader) TimovieMan, furgotten, millenia. Lady Kestrel, Iznogood
5 Lost Lands - The Four Horsemen Tim (leader) TimovieMan, cluelass, Becky, Dara100
4 9: The Dark Side TimovieMan, furgotten, Sefir, chrissie
4 Azada in Libro Sefir (leader) Tim, Becky, Lady Kestrel
3 Shiver - PoltergeistTim (leader) TimovieMan, millenia
3 Dark Realm: Queen of Flames Becky (leader) Tim, cluelass
3 Nightmare Adventure: The Witches Prison Becky (leader) Sefir, Lady Kestrel
3 Maze - Subject 360 Lady Kestrel (leader) Tim, chrissie
2 Myths of the World - Of Fiends and Fairies Tim (leader) TimovieMan
2 Fantastic Creations: House of Brass cluelass (leader) Tim
2 Depths of Betrayal Tim (leader) cluelass
1 Beyond:Light Advent Becky (leader)
The tie is temporarily broken. Still very close with four games within two votes of each other. One of those games currently has no leader. Voting will close at midnight, Wednesday, August 26 CDT. Or, if we go two consecutive days without a vote/nomination
change, we might pull the plug.
Interesting situation with ties. There was also a tie in the recent AGCPT vote. It was decided by having the five people who voted for both games recast their vote, with the stipulation that they could only vote for one game. Syberia 2 won with three votes. Nobody voted for all of the top four games. So it looks like we might have to look for a different way to resolve the issue should it come up.
Note: All games except Maze are available in both SE and CE versions on BFG. Currently Maze is only available as a CE.
For whom the games toll,
they toll for thee.
Vote total as of August 24 (Last post for the day. No Change)
6 Surface: The Noise She Couldn’t Make chrissie (leader) TimovieMan, furgotten, millenia. Lady Kestrel, Iznogood
5 Lost Lands - The Four Horsemen Tim (leader) TimovieMan, cluelass, Becky, Dara100
4 9: The Dark Side TimovieMan, furgotten, Sefir, chrissie
4 Azada in Libro Sefir (leader) Tim, Becky, Lady Kestrel
3 Shiver - PoltergeistTim (leader) TimovieMan, millenia
3 Dark Realm: Queen of Flames Becky (leader) Tim, cluelass
3 Nightmare Adventure: The Witches Prison Becky (leader) Sefir, Lady Kestrel
3 Maze - Subject 360 Lady Kestrel (leader) Tim, chrissie
2 Myths of the World - Of Fiends and Fairies Tim (leader) TimovieMan
2 Fantastic Creations: House of Brass cluelass (leader) Tim
2 Depths of Betrayal Tim (leader) cluelass
1 Beyond:Light Advent Becky (leader)
The tie is temporarily broken. Still very close with four games within two votes of each other. One of those games currently has no leader. Voting will close at midnight, Wednesday, August 26 CDT. Or, if we go two consecutive days without a vote/nomination
change, we might pull the plug. That would mean tomorrow if there are no more votes.
Interesting situation with ties. There was also a tie in the recent AGCPT vote. It was decided by having the five people who voted for both games recast their vote, with the stipulation that they could only vote for one game. Syberia 2 won with three votes. Nobody voted for all of the top four games. So it looks like we might have to look for a different way to resolve the issue should it come up. (BTW, that way would have been allowing everyone who voted one vote for whatever games were tied.) I’m sure the problem will come up again. Another BTW is that a winning game must have a leader. That’s always been the case.
Note: All games except Maze are available in both SE and CE versions on BFG. Currently Maze is only available as a CE.
For whom the games toll,
they toll for thee.
Vote total as of August 25 (Last post for the day. No Change)
6 Surface: The Noise She Couldn’t Make chrissie (leader) TimovieMan, furgotten, millenia. Lady Kestrel, Iznogood
5 Lost Lands - The Four Horsemen Tim (leader) TimovieMan, cluelass, Becky, Dara100
4 9: The Dark Side TimovieMan, furgotten, Sefir, chrissie
4 Azada in Libro Sefir (leader) Tim, Becky, Lady Kestrel
3 Shiver - PoltergeistTim (leader) TimovieMan, millenia
3 Dark Realm: Queen of Flames Becky (leader) Tim, cluelass
3 Nightmare Adventure: The Witches Prison Becky (leader) Sefir, Lady Kestrel
3 Maze - Subject 360 Lady Kestrel (leader) Tim, chrissie
2 Myths of the World - Of Fiends and Fairies Tim (leader) TimovieMan
2 Fantastic Creations: House of Brass cluelass (leader) Tim
2 Depths of Betrayal Tim (leader) cluelass
1 Beyond:Light Advent Becky (leader)
It’s only one more day. So we might as well let the vote play out.
Still haven’t heard from Colpet and Crabapple. But, if nothing new happens before tomorrow night, we will have a winner. chrissie, get ready to don your leadership robes.
Note: All games except Maze are available in both SE and CE versions on BFG. Currently Maze is only available as a CE.
For whom the games toll,
they toll for thee.
I haven’t voted because I’m going to be away for the last half of September. I’m interested in playing Maze 360, but a vote for that wouldn’t have made a difference to the frontrunner.
Vote total as of August 25 (Last post for the day. No Change)
6 Surface: The Noise She Couldn’t Make chrissie (leader) TimovieMan, furgotten, millenia. Lady Kestrel, Iznogood
5 Lost Lands - The Four Horsemen Tim (leader) TimovieMan, cluelass, Becky, Dara100
4 9: The Dark Side TimovieMan, furgotten, Sefir, chrissie
4 Azada in Libro Sefir (leader) Tim, Becky, Lady Kestrel
3 Shiver - PoltergeistTim (leader) TimovieMan, millenia
3 Dark Realm: Queen of Flames Becky (leader) Tim, cluelass
3 Nightmare Adventure: The Witches Prison Becky (leader) Sefir, Lady Kestrel
3 Maze - Subject 360 Lady Kestrel (leader) Tim, chrissie
2 Myths of the World - Of Fiends and Fairies Tim (leader) TimovieMan
2 Fantastic Creations: House of Brass cluelass (leader) Tim
2 Depths of Betrayal Tim (leader) cluelass
1 Beyond:Light Advent Becky (leader)
It’s only one more day. So we might as well let the vote play out.Still haven’t heard from Colpet and Crabapple. But, if nothing new happens before tomorrow night, we will have a winner. chrissie, get ready to don your leadership robes.
Note: All games except Maze are available in both SE and CE versions on BFG. Currently Maze is only available as a CE.
I’m ready! 
(I’m so surprised that the game got ahead .....well so far!)
Final Vote Total
6 Surface: The Noise She Couldn’t Make chrissie (leader) TimovieMan, furgotten, millenia. Lady Kestrel, Iznogood
5 Lost Lands - The Four Horsemen Tim (leader) TimovieMan, cluelass, Becky, Dara100
4 9: The Dark Side TimovieMan, furgotten, Sefir, chrissie
4 Azada in Libro Sefir (leader) Tim, Becky, Lady Kestrel
Surface: The Noise She Couldn’t Make is the winner.
I listed the rest if only to show how close the vote was.
chrissie, as you said, your robes are ready. We await your playthrough posting and TimovieMan’s pinning it.
I must admit I’m a bit jealous. It’s been awhile since I had a chance to lead a CCPT game. I was looking forward to doing another one. But I’m happy that you’re doing your first here. It is going to be great. I have the game. I like the game. Let’s have some fun.
For whom the games toll,
they toll for thee.
OK! It’s hard to believe that it’s been almost a month since we finished the last playthrough. So I guess its about time that we start thinking about a new one.
Following is the list of games that received at least one vote. But just because they got a vote doesn’t mean they are automatically on the ballot. Each game needs to be re-nominated, and find a leader. Only those games that are renominated will be on the next ballot.
Lost Lands - The Four Horsemen
9: The Dark Side
Azada in Libro
Shiver - Poltergeist
Dark Realm: Queen of Flames
Nightmare Adventure: The Witches Prison
Maze - Subject 360
Myths of the World - Of Fiends and Fairies
Fantastic Creations: House of Brass
Depths of Betrayal
Beyond:Light Advent
For whom the games toll,
they toll for thee.
I will nominate Lost Lands - The Four Horsemen, and will lead it as well.
For whom the games toll,
they toll for thee.
I’ve been looking forward to Lost Land: The Four Horsemen so I vote for that as well.
I can’t offer to lead anything until after the autumn challenge, so I will play whatever is on offer.
“Rainy days should be spent at home with a cup of tea and a good book.” -Bill Watterson
I nominate and offer to lead Azada in Libro.
I also vote for Lost Lands - The Four Horsemen.
Again, a well-deserved thank you to Chrissie for leading our last playthrough. Insert sounds of hands clapping and image of a standing ovation!
Vote total as of October 7
3 Lost Lands - The Four Horsemen Tim (leader) Becky, Sefir, TimovieMan
2 Azada in Libro Sefir (leader) Tim
So far, with only two nominations, it’s a close race. 
For whom the games toll,
they toll for thee.
Add my vote to Lost Lands. 
The truth can’t hurt you, it’s just like the dark: it scares you witless but in time you see things clear and stark. - Elvis Costello
Maybe this time I can be strong, but since I know who I am, I’m probably wrong. Maybe this time I can go far, but thinking about where I’ve been ain’t helping me start. - Michael Kiwanuka
Done! But it’s going to be a pretty boring vote if we only have two nominees!
For whom the games toll,
they toll for thee.
You are here: Home → Forum Home → Gaming → Adventure → Thread
