Adventure Gamers - Forums

7 - Monkey Island 2
5 - Heavy Rain
3 - Blackwell Epiphany
2 - Tales of Monkey Island
1 - Fahrenheit

I like both Simon the Sorcerer and even the deeply-flawed The Black Mirror quite a lot,but I got bigger impacts playing the David Cage games. Heavy Rain I actually really rate highly in spite of itself- it gave me my most memorable experience on the PS3 by a considerable margin. I actually found it quite engrossing and I don’t think it fell away story-wise to the same extent Fahrenheit did. I found it quite satisfying first time through, even.

Blackwell was a really fitting end, and MI5 I consider superior to both MI3 and MI4, but full points have to go to the game with my absolute favourite ending ever in it.

Monkey Island 2: LeChuck’s Revenge 7
Black Mirror 5
Simon the Sorcerer 3

7 - Monkey Island 2: LeChuck’s Revenge
5 - Blackwell Epiphany
3 - Tales of Monkey Island
2 - Indigo Prophecy (aka Fahrenheit)
1 - Heavy Rain

7 - MI2
5 - Blackwell Epiphany
3 - Fahrenheit (would love to play Heavy Rain but I don’t want to buy a PS3 just for this)
2 - Black Mirror

Meh, I’ll just vote now.  I don’t think I’ll have time to play Blackwell Epiphany this week after all, and it doesn’t look like it’ll need my support to advance anyway.

7 - Heavy Rain
5 - Monkey Island 2

Tales of Monkey Island - 7
Fahreheit - 5
Heavy Rain - 3
Monkey Island 2 - 2
The Black Mirror - 1

7: Monkey Island 2: LeChuck’s Revenge
5: Blackwell Epiphany
3: Tales of Monkey Island
2: Simon the Sorcerer
1: Hotel Dusk: Room 215

I’ve said before that I’m pretty lukewarm towards Cing’s games, but when the only competition is Fahrenheit (which was all right) and The Black Mirror (which was terrible), it manages to squeeze in comfortably.

Not sure ToMI deserves a higher rank than Simon, but I still remember how magical it felt to play a new installment in the Monkey Island series after all those years, so it’s possible that I’m letting my emotions influence the vote too much. Again.

I haven’t played Heavy Rain yet and the biggest reason is indeed that it’s PS3 only.

7 The Black Mirror
5 Blackwell Epiphany
3 Heavy Rain
2 Monkey Island 2
1 Indigo Prophecy

I like all 5 of these games as much as each other so it was difficult to decide what order to put them in!

7 - Monkey Island 2
5 - The Black Mirror
3 - Heavy Rain
2 - Tales of Monkey Island
1 - Blackwell Epiphany

7 - The Black Mirror
5 - Simon the Sorcerer
3 - MI2