[Lucifiel]

Black mirror, I think. It was very atmospheric and I really enjoyed the puzzles. In the game, I really felt like I'd been sucked into some incredible universe of mysteries and puzzles. The only problem was the ending: good lords.

Spoiler:

I'd have put up with a heirloom that the main character always wore, as being the source of all evil, but him being evil? Geez, what a twist but also a disappointment as he chose to kill himself.

Hmmm... TLJ would have come close to this description. It was fun in many senses: the puzzles, the stories, etc. but the ending sort of blew the well-constructed story away. Plus, I felt that some of the characters could've been fleshed out a little bit more.