I think I get it.
You have an extra item and you're missing the instructions. You've done the dance so I guess the instructions disappeared. As for the pom pom on a string, at a guess, you probably got that from the pink paladin. Darned if I remember.
Now what you
do with it...
Wait...now I recall. You got that from something that belongs to the pink paladin.
If you need a walkthrough (I seriously suggest you don't use it), MaG has a good one at Gameboomers.
