Personally I think the classic more realistic approach were great styles they should have build on. You can still be goofy without having to look goofy too. By the look of the character potraits sketches, there was some nice ideas you can see that looks closer to the originals but unfortunately they did not go that route.
http://i203.photobucket.com/albums/a...lliams/1-5.png
look at the middle one!
The remake one is pretty loyal, and if you dont like it you can always switch to the old.
The third game had so much personality but I never liked guybrushes design though...
The new episodic one looks pretty dead to me, probably due to their engine they are using. As if you look at the sketches they have for that game its not bad. Its just how they manage to make it into 3d that makes it look horrible..
