Well to push April a bit further up the list, and to finally make a post as opposed to just lurking as I've been doing for the past couple of years, here's mine...
10 Lucas Kane
9 Peter Wright
8 Ben from Full Throttle
7 Zöe - Not got the wit of April, but well drawn-out
6 Sam
5 George Stobbart - the naive adventurer to a "t"
4 Gabriel Knight - Tim Curry & some of the writing in GK3 just overplays the boorishness a bit too much for my taste. But still fantastic overall.
3 Guybrush Threepwood - The perfect Pirate
Only Gaby & Grace rival him for one-liners as far as my memory goes...
2 Grace Nakimura - 3 games & 3 3 actors & yet they all do a great job. The perfect foil for Gaby.
1 April Ryan - what more can you want? Realistic, well-acted, character develops over time (& in both games), and just really likeable.
Not wanting to be a trouble-stirrer, but Victoria McPherson & Kate Walker just don't cut it as complex female characters compared to the three above
