Quote:
|
Originally Posted by Ninth
Hm, I have to disagree, here, at least regarding JA.
I think they are biased, seeing how Space quest 1 and 5 got an A rating, while Monkey Island got a C and Indy3 Ã* D.
To me, that's blatantly unfair.
|
Yes, but DOTT got A, CMI got A, Grim Fandango got A, Full Throttle got A, Indy FOA got A, need go on?
So you disagree with two ratings and that's supposed to make JA biased?
Also note that the scores for Sierra's games are quite diverse too. They're not all getting A and B scores!
Quote:
Furthermore, I think it's weird that a guy who admits he doesn't like 3rd person game to review MI, or any Lucas game for that matter. Especially stating at the beginning that he knows he is voicing an unpopular opinion.
I mean, I'm fine with controversial reviews, as long as you can find another review to balance it, but here it's not the case; just an infamous C.
|
True, but that's a whole other discussion. I'd lie if I'd say I agree with Ray Ivey's MI and MI2 reviews. But that's just a personal opinion of course.
Quote:
|
I'm angry. Too bad I don't know how to make the appropriate smiley.
|
How about
:
--Erwin
