The Walking Dead: Season Two - Episode 4: Amid the Ruins review

The Walking Dead: Season Two - Episode 4: Amid the Ruins
The Walking Dead: Season Two - Episode 4: Amid the Ruins
The Good:
  • Strong character development and interactions
  • Surprises are plenty as the story twists around each corner
  • Varied and well-paced gameplay
  • Usual appealing presentation and great voice acting
  • Fantastic cliffhanger ending offers no hints at the series’ ultimate conclusion
The Bad:
  • Illusion of choice is particularly apparent as linear events play out
  • Too little time spent portraying emotion in the aftermath of traumatic events
  • Only around 90 minutes in length
Our Verdict:

Amid The Ruins really delivers in setting the stage for the series conclusion, creating both expected and unexpected challenges that strike at the heart of fragile group dynamics.

The fourth instalment of The Walking Dead’s second season, Amid the Ruins, removes whatever slim hopes might have remained for a peaceful conclusion, as the penultimate episode brings the group to their lowest point with a barrage of obstacles and continual conflicts that see death and dysfunction become commonplace before reaching its gripping cliffhanger ending. It’s a grim episode that packs a slew of surprise punches, making it one of the most engaging this season.

Resuming right where the last episode left off, we first find Clementine faced with the aftermath of her (or rather, your) earlier choice to hatchet a companion’s limb or the zombie attached to it. It’s a traumatic introduction that sets the tone for the episode as a whole, an ultimately morbid affair that plummets the short-lived relief of escaping the Carver's clutches into a state of perpetual despair.

This episode revolves around the group trying to decide their next steps and secure a safe haven. Since this is The Walking Dead, of course, such a process is never straightforward. Taumatised by recent events, Kenny has become is a broken man, a shadow of his former self, while Rebecca is on the verge of delivering her child prematurely and Sarah is almost literally paralysed by fear.

Once again Clementine functions as the group’s crutch, working harder than all of the adults combined to maintain morale and keep everyone moving forward. Sarah, whose immaturity has always been something of a burden, once again relies on Clementine to function as her protector, to the extent where, in dire situations and against the group’s advice, I found myself unable to give up on her. As a polar opposite, Jane comes out of her shell in this episode as a guardian, teaching Clementine valuable advice and expressing a somewhat reluctant fondness for her young friend. This instilled in me a similar sense of nurturing protection for Clementine that Lee inspired in season one. Their interactions are delicately handled and intertwined with past memories, such as a reference Jane makes with regard to Clementine’s hair being tied back.

This close emotional connection to Clementine frequently resulted in my picking dialogue options and making tough choices based on what I felt a matured and kind-hearted Clementine would do rather than what I as a player perceived to be the best option. That made the decisions feel ever more impactful, especially given how uncertain their eventual outcomes would be. I found myself shrieking on multiple occasions as I witnessed the aftermath of choices I had anxiously considered before the timer ran out.

Unfortunately, this illusion of choice, a trick that’s been executed with mixed results throughout the series, proves to be particularly transparent in Amid the Ruins. Though not immediately obvious when first confronted with them, the majority of decisions that appear to divert the story in a particular direction always comes back to a singular path a few scenes later, and all attempts to avoid inevitable outcomes are in vain.

Kenny is once again another highlight, as he has been for the series as a whole. Once an angry and selfish man, this season he’s become a more refined and selfless character who shares in Clementine’s hardships. However, there’s a glimpse of Kenny’s prior chaotic, impulsive emotion in this episode as he turns against the group, raising fear for his own safety and those around him. This disturbing downturn was a frightful reminder of the disdain I had for Kenny, and of the history he and Clementine shared, in the previous season. Thankfully it doesn’t last too long before events get out of control and he resumes position as the group’s leader, helping establish a plan of action.

On the flipside, there’s an inconsistency in the portrayal of both Luke and Rebecca. Luke, a prior favourite of mine, makes a string of moronic decisions along with turning into a complainer, continually whinging throughout the episode. Rebecca, on the other hand, looks to have completely forgotten about your prior disagreements as you suddenly get along like close friends.

Where prior episodes have lacked much action, instead focusing too much on conversation, Amid the Ruins swings a little too far in the opposite direction. On multiple occasions there are shocking scenes that pass almost unnoticed or are mentioned only in passing. One particular example sees Luke brush off what should have been a devastating experience in an emotionless sentence. Another sees the whole group overlook a companion’s death with barely a word uttered between them. This episode sorely lacks the calm in between the roller coaster highs and lows to let the significance of the latest horrific events sink in. Given the short playtime of around 90 minutes, there was certainly ample room to slow down the pacing with additional relevant dialogue interactions.

The more interaction-oriented gameplay this time around includes a handful of Quick Time Events, in the form of both stabbing and shooting zombie threats, and also a welcome return to light puzzle segments. The latter require at least a bit of environmental investigation to progress the story, such as needing to distract a horde of zombies with what’s at hand or identifying a good prop to aid the group’s escape. It’s all very easy and straightforward but adds some very welcome variety.

Removing the group from Carver’s drab cells allows for a much-needed visual change in a handful of new locations. Having distanced themselves from the zombie horde, the group opt to let Rebecca get some rest at a Civil War memorial site whilst small scouting parties search the surrounding areas. This includes the forests that separate you from the invading walkers, a museum interior and an accompanying observation deck and gift shop. Each location, whilst confined in scope, offers a degree of interactivity and serves to section off the characters, allowing for intimate discussions and intergroup bickering. You’re initially presented with a choice of locations to visit when the group split apart, but this choice is only temporary as you’ll visit the alternate area directly after the first.

Graphically the game looks great once again, its iconic comic book style able to convey emotion from facial expressions alone and maintain the grim atmosphere even in the wide outdoors in moderate daylight. The voice acting is as stellar as ever, even without the benefit of Carver’s Michael Madsen for the first time this season.

Whilst the lack of true choice quickly becomes apparent, this doesn’t dilute the fact that the story unfolding is extremely potent, with a barrage of conflict, a steady stream of despair, and enough surprise twists to keep it all feeling fresh throughout. Between losing old acquaintances and encountering new ones, there are more memorable moments that took me by surprise in this episode than in any previous instalment, and it ends on yet another stunning cliffhanger. Even better, Amid the Ruins opts out of an end credits preview reel of what to expect from the final episode, leaving the mystery of what’s in store at an all-time high.


Readers rating

Very good

4 stars out of 5
Average based on 11 ratings

What's your verdict?

Want to share your own thoughts about this game? Share your personal score, or better yet, leave your own review!

Adventure games by Telltale Games

The Wolf Among Us: Season Two: Episode Five  2018

PC Mac Android iOS iPhone iPad PS PS4 Xbox Xbox One

The Wolf Among Us: Season Two: Episode Four  2018

PC Mac Android iOS iPhone iPad PS PS4 Xbox Xbox One

The Wolf Among Us: Season Two: Episode Three  2018

PC Mac Android iOS iPhone iPad PS PS4 Xbox Xbox One

The Wolf Among Us: Season Two: Episode Two  2018

PC Mac Android iOS iPhone iPad PS PS4 Xbox Xbox One

The Wolf Among Us: Season Two: Episode One  2018

PC Mac Android iOS iPhone iPad PS PS4 Xbox Xbox One

The Walking Dead: The Final Season – Episode Four  2018

PC Mac Android iOS iPhone iPad PS PS4 Xbox Xbox One

The Walking Dead: The Final Season – Episode Three  2018

PC Mac Android iOS iPhone iPad PS PS4 Xbox Xbox One

The Walking Dead: The Final Season – Episode Two  2018

PC Mac Android iOS iPhone iPad PS PS4 Xbox Xbox One

The Walking Dead: The Final Season – Episode One  2018

PC Mac Android iOS iPhone iPad PS PS4 Xbox Xbox One

Batman: The Enemy Within – The Telltale Series: Episode Five – Same Stitch  2018

PC Mac Android iOS iPhone iPad PS PS4 Xbox Xbox One

Batman: The Enemy Within – The Telltale Series: Episode Four – What Ails You  2018

PC Mac Android iOS iPhone iPad PS PS4 Xbox Xbox One

Batman: The Enemy Within – The Telltale Series: Episode Three – Fractured Mask  2017

PC Mac Android iOS iPhone iPad PS PS4 Xbox Xbox One

Batman: The Enemy Within – The Telltale Series: Episode Two – The Pact  2017

PC Mac Android iOS iPhone iPad PS PS4 Xbox Xbox One

The Walking Dead: The Final Season  2018

PC Mac Android iOS iPhone iPad PS PS4 Xbox Xbox One

The Wolf Among Us: Season Two  2018

PC Mac Android iOS iPhone iPad PS PS4 Xbox Xbox One

Batman: The Enemy Within – The Telltale Series  2017

PC Mac Android iOS iPhone iPad PS PS4 Xbox Xbox One Switch

Minecraft: Story Mode – Season Two: Episode 5 – Above and Beyond  2017

PC Mac Android iOS iPhone iPad PS PS4 Xbox Xbox One

Minecraft: Story Mode – Season Two: Episode 4 – Below the Bedrock  2017

PC Mac Android iOS iPhone iPad PS PS4 Xbox Xbox One

Minecraft: Story Mode – Season Two: Episode 3 – Jailhouse Block  2017

PC Mac Android iOS iPhone iPad PS PS4 Xbox Xbox One

Minecraft: Story Mode – Season Two: Episode 2 – Giant Consequences  2017

PC Mac Android iOS iPhone iPad PS PS4 Xbox Xbox One

Minecraft: Story Mode – Season Two: Episode 1 – Hero in Residence  2017

PC Mac Android iOS iPhone iPad PS PS4 Xbox Xbox One

Minecraft: Story Mode – Season Two  2017

PC Mac Android iOS iPhone iPad PS PS4 Xbox Xbox One

Marvel’s Guardians of the Galaxy: The Telltale Series  2017

PC Mac Android iOS iPhone iPad PS PS4 Xbox Xbox One

Batman: The Telltale Series - Episode Five: City of Light  2016

PC Mac Android iOS iPhone iPad PS PS4 PS3 Xbox Xbox One Xbox 360 Switch

Batman: The Telltale Series - Episode Four: Guardian of Gotham  2016

PC Mac Android iOS iPhone iPad PS PS4 PS3 Xbox Xbox One Xbox 360 Switch

Batman: The Telltale Series - Episode Three: New World Order  2016

PC Mac Android iOS iPhone iPad PS PS4 PS3 Xbox Xbox One Xbox 360 Switch

Batman: The Telltale Series - Episode Two: Children of Arkham  2016

PC Mac Android iOS iPhone iPad PS PS4 PS3 Xbox Xbox One Xbox 360 Switch

Batman: The Telltale Series - Episode One: Realm of Shadows  2016

PC Mac Android iOS iPhone iPad PS PS4 PS3 Xbox Xbox One Xbox 360 Switch

Minecraft: Story Mode - Episode 8: A Journey’s End?  2016

PC Mac Android iOS iPhone iPad PS PS4 PS3 Xbox Xbox One Xbox 360 Switch Wii WiiU

Minecraft: Story Mode - Episode 7: Access Denied  2016

PC Mac Android iOS iPhone iPad PS PS4 PS3 Xbox Xbox One Xbox 360 Switch Wii WiiU

Minecraft: Story Mode - Episode 6: A Portal to Mystery  2016

PC Mac Android iOS iPhone iPad PS PS4 PS3 Xbox Xbox One Xbox 360 Switch Wii WiiU

The Walking Dead: Michonne: Episode Three - What We Deserve  2016

PC Mac Android iOS iPhone iPad PS PS4 PS3 Xbox Xbox One Xbox 360

The Walking Dead: Michonne: Episode Two - Give No Shelter  2016

PC Mac Android iOS iPhone iPad PS PS4 PS3 Xbox Xbox One Xbox 360

The Walking Dead: Michonne: Episode One - In Too Deep  2016

PC Mac Android iOS iPhone iPad PS PS4 PS3 Xbox Xbox One Xbox 360

Batman: The Telltale Series  2016

A new episodic Telltale game series based on the popular DC Comics franchise.

PC Mac Android iOS iPhone iPad PS PS4 PS3 Xbox Xbox One Xbox 360

Minecraft: Story Mode - Episode 5: Order Up!  2016

PC Mac Android iOS iPhone iPad PS PS4 PS3 Xbox Xbox One Xbox 360 Switch Wii WiiU

Minecraft: Story Mode - Episode 4: A Block and a Hard Place  2015

PC Mac Android iOS iPhone iPad PS PS4 PS3 Xbox Xbox One Xbox 360 Switch Wii WiiU

Minecraft: Story Mode - Episode 3: The Last Place You Look  2015

PC Mac Android iOS iPhone iPad PS PS4 PS3 Xbox Xbox One Xbox 360 Switch Wii WiiU

Minecraft: Story Mode - Episode 2: Assembly Required  2015

PC Mac Android iOS iPhone iPad PS PS4 PS3 Xbox Xbox One Xbox 360 Switch Wii WiiU

Minecraft: Story Mode - Episode 1: The Order of the Stone  2015

PC Mac Android iOS iPhone iPad PS PS4 PS3 Xbox Xbox One Xbox 360 Switch Wii WiiU

The Walking Dead: Michonne  2016

PC Mac Android iOS iPhone iPad PS PS4 PS3 Xbox Xbox One Xbox 360

Tales from the Borderlands: Episode Five - The Vault of the Traveler  2015

PC Mac Android iOS iPhone iPad PS PS4 PS3 Xbox Xbox One Xbox 360

Tales from the Borderlands: Episode Four - Escape Plan Bravo  2015

PC Mac Android iOS iPhone iPad PS PS4 PS3 Xbox Xbox One Xbox 360

Tales from the Borderlands: Episode Three - Catch a Ride  2015

PC Mac Android iOS iPhone iPad PS PS4 PS3 Xbox Xbox One Xbox 360

Tales from the Borderlands: Episode Two - Atlas Mugged  2015

PC Mac Android iOS iPhone iPad PS PS4 PS3 Xbox Xbox One Xbox 360

Game of Thrones: Episode Six - The Ice Dragon  2015

PC Mac Android iOS iPhone iPad PS PS4 PS3 Xbox Xbox One Xbox 360

Game of Thrones: Episode Five - A Nest of Vipers  2015

PC Mac Android iOS iPhone iPad PS PS4 PS3 Xbox Xbox One Xbox 360

Game of Thrones: Episode Four - Sons of Winter  2015

PC Mac Android iOS iPhone iPad PS PS4 PS3 Xbox Xbox One Xbox 360

Game of Thrones: Episode Three - The Sword in the Darkness  2015

PC Mac Android iOS iPhone iPad PS PS4 PS3 Xbox Xbox One Xbox 360

Game of Thrones: Episode Two - The Lost Lords  2015

PC Mac Android iOS iPhone iPad PS PS4 PS3 Xbox Xbox One Xbox 360

Minecraft: Story Mode  2016

A five-part episodic Telltale game series set in the world of Minecraft.

PC Mac Android iOS iPhone iPad PS PS4 PS3 Xbox Xbox One Xbox 360 Switch Wii WiiU

Game of Thrones: Episode One - Iron from Ice  2014

PC Mac Android iOS iPhone iPad PS PS4 PS3 Xbox Xbox One Xbox 360

Tales from the Borderlands: Episode One - Zer0 Sum  2014

PC Mac Android iOS iPhone iPad PS PS4 PS3 Xbox Xbox One Xbox 360

The Walking Dead: A New Frontier  2017

PC Mac Android iOS iPhone iPad PS PS4 Xbox Xbox One

The Walking Dead: Season Two - Episode Five: No Going Back  2014

PC Mac Android iOS iPhone iPad PS PS3 Xbox Xbox 360

The Walking Dead: Season Two - Episode Four: Amid the Ruins  2014

PC Mac Android iOS iPhone iPad PS PS Vita PS3 Xbox Xbox 360

The Walking Dead: Season Two - Episode Three: In Harm’s Way  2014

PC Mac Android iOS iPhone iPad PS PS3 Xbox Xbox 360

The Walking Dead: Season Two - Episode Two: A House Divided  2014

PC Mac Android iOS iPhone iPad PS PS3 Xbox Xbox 360

The Walking Dead: Season Two - Episode One: All That Remains  2013

PC Mac Android iOS iPhone iPad PS PS3 Xbox Xbox 360

Game of Thrones  2015

A six-part episodic series from Telltale Games based on the HBO fantasy series.

PC Mac Android iOS iPhone iPad PS PS4 PS3 Xbox Xbox One Xbox 360

Tales from the Borderlands  2015

PC Mac Android iOS iPhone iPad PS PS4 PS3 Xbox Xbox One Xbox 360

The Walking Dead: Season Two  2014

PC Mac Android iOS iPhone iPad PS PS3 Xbox Xbox 360

The Wolf Among Us: Episode Five - Cry Wolf  2014

PC Mac iOS iPhone iPad PS PS3 Xbox Xbox 360

The Wolf Among Us: Episode Four - In Sheep’s Clothing  2014

PC Mac iOS iPhone iPad PS PS3 Xbox Xbox 360

The Wolf Among Us: Episode Three: A Crooked Mile  2014

PC Mac iOS iPhone iPad PS PS3 Xbox Xbox 360

The Wolf Among Us: Episode Two - Smoke & Mirrors  2014

PC Mac iOS iPhone iPad PS PS3 Xbox Xbox 360

The Wolf Among Us: Episode One - Faith  2013

An episodic adventure from Telltale based on the popular FABLES comic series.

PC Mac iOS iPhone iPad PS PS3 Xbox Xbox 360

The Walking Dead: 400 Days  2013

PC Mac iOS iPhone iPad PS PS3 Xbox Xbox 360

The Walking Dead: Episode Five - No Time Left  2012

Zombie apocalypse adventure based on Robert Kirkman's award-winning comic book series.

PC Mac Android iOS iPhone iPad PS PS3 Xbox Xbox 360

Puzzle Agent 2  2011

PC Mac iPhone iPad

Law & Order: Legacies  2011

PC Mac iPhone iPad

The Wolf Among Us  2014

An episodic adventure from Telltale based on the popular FABLES comic series.

PC Mac PS PS3 Xbox Xbox 360

The Walking Dead  2012

PC Mac Android iOS iPhone iPad PS PS3 Xbox Xbox 360

Back to the Future: The Game  2011

PC Mac Wii PS4 PS3 Xbox One Xbox 360

Back to the Future: Episode 5 - OUTATIME  2011

PC Mac Wii PS4 PS3 Xbox One Xbox 360

Back to the Future: Episode 4 - Double Visions  2011

PC Mac Wii PS4 PS3 Xbox One Xbox 360

Back to the Future: Episode 3 - Citizen Brown  2011

PC Mac Wii PS4 PS3 Xbox One Xbox 360

Back to the Future: Episode 2 - Get Tannen!  2011

PC Mac Wii PS4 PS3 Xbox One Xbox 360

CSI: Fatal Conspiracy  2010

PC Wii PS3 Xbox 360