Return to Mysterious Island review - page 2

The Good:
  • Can we say... inventory puzzles? Lots of 'em, and they're fun! Beautiful graphics
  • Great sound effects
  • Clever use of Verne's backstory.
The Bad:
  • Cinematically bare-bones
  • Inventory management gets cumbersome
  • Abrupt ending.
Our Verdict: Tailor-made for inventory lovers, but plenty here for every adventure gamer to enjoy. It's simple and modest, but offers great value for your gaming dollar.

The most intriguing part of the various inventory puzzles in RMI is something that many people (who, me?) have moaned long and loud about wanting to see incorporated into more adventures: multiple solutions! Not every puzzle has more than one option, but many do, and this provides a welcome relief from the rigid design of most games. As RMI alternates between linear and non-linear segments, involving lots of naturally camouflaged items (though not quite pixel hunts, as all items are plainly visible), it's great that progress is rarely halted by an inability to find one unknown object. As an added benefit, the extra options increase the number of puzzles for those determined to find the alternatives. The game encourages seeking out these secondary solutions by providing a point scoring system to measure your success, and by offering bonus art at various point levels. It's the best of both worlds, folks. Go Kheops!

Unfortunately, there are a few weaknesses in the inventory system that slightly hinder the experience. To begin with, the sheer size of the inventory is simply too unwieldy. To give you an idea of its scope, at one random moment I counted 62 individual items either sitting loosely, in mid-assembly, or fully combined with other objects in my inventory. Finding them all involved clicking through several main inventory tabs and the assembly scrollbar, meaning I'd rarely have all the items I wanted on the same screen at one time. This is too cumbersome to navigate repeatedly. There is also a temporary "transit" place for new items collected that serves absolutely no purpose except to make me have to empty it into the main inventory manually.

Another problem is that Mina will often start combining items long before I know what she is trying to build, which lessens the immersion factor. Eventually I would find a clue or figure it out myself, but by then I'd begun to feel like a passenger in someone else's story. This also causes some logistical problems for puzzle solving, as any item in mid-assembly cannot be used in another combination. So between a massively-bloated inventory, multiple solutions and complex assemblies I didn't understand, I still ended up resorting to "try everything on everything" too often. If ever a game needed an automatic discard for items no longer useful, RMI is it. Surely if Mina knows what items she needs before I do, she'd also know what items have become obsolete. So with a better clue system and a more streamlined inventory interface, RMI would have been far more intuitive, but despite the room for improvement, it's still the most fun I've had with inventory in a long, long time.

By now puzzle lovers will be wondering if there's anything BUT inventory puzzles in the game, and there certainly is. In fact, the latter stage of the game sees a surprising focus shift from inventory to other types of conventional logic puzzles like pattern-matching, jigsaw, and slider-style puzzles, plus a fabulous riddle sequence (though a little uneven in difficulty). There's also a musical puzzle, but breathe easy; it's optional. While the change in gameplay is justified by the narrative, it may leave inventory lovers feeling abandoned, and have abstract puzzle lovers wondering what took so long, and I'm not sure either will be entirely satisfied by the abrupt switch. If you enjoy both, of course, you're laughing. So the variety is there; just be aware that the distribution is anything but proportional.

For anyone who feels heart palpitations from seeing screenshots with a "health bar", rest assured that there are no horrific timed action sequences in Return to Mysterious Island. The health bars themselves are merely progress indicators, and while there are a couple of timed sequences, they are also optional (think "puzzle" and work around them if you wish). There are also some very basic mandatory gun shooting requirements, but even a one-eyed gamer with cataracts couldn't fail to accomplish them. I mean that! The first person to mention the shooting gallery in Wanted/The Westerner gets voted off the island... wait, no, we want off the island, so that person has to STAY. The point being, there is no comparison. RMI is as user-friendly an adventure as they come.

It may seem strange that I've neglected plot this long for a game inspired by Verne's own The Mysterious Island, but really it's not particularly relevant to much of the gameplay. As the game's title suggests, RMI takes place after the events of Verne's famous 19th century tale of Captain Nemo and the five men originally stranded on Lincoln Island. Not only is no prior knowledge of the novel necessary, but anyone who has read the book will know that Kheops had to fudge the ending of Verne's story in order to allow a "Return" (although, to their credit, they cleverly justify it during the game). And since the game assumes that Mina doesn't know the island's history, you'll be piecing together past events along with her. So while readers of Verne's novel will take additional pleasure in revisiting familiar locations in graphic form, newcomers won't feel at all left behind.

While the historical record of the five Verne companions is learned only through clues pieced together along the way, Captain Nemo and the Nautilus may yet be directly bound to the island. Mina is plagued by dreams and glimpses of an ethereal figure that compel her forward, though she cannot interact with him. Of course I can't say more, but suffice to say that Mina's fate becomes inextricably linked to Nemo's impact on the island.

Regrettably, the building narrative momentum coincides with the dramatic shift in gameplay and puzzle design, and it's too much, too fast, making RMI feel far less cohesive than it should. Moreover, just when you adjust to the new dynamics... the game ends! I'm not disappointed in the conclusion so much as I feel I hadn't been prepared for it, or done enough to feel I'd deserved it. My first time through, I hadn't yet accomplished what I considered to be a major plot task (I can't tell you, so don't ask), and was stunned to realize it wasn't integral to completion. My corresponding low point score merely mocked me, saying "You pathetic fool! Why are you here so early when there's so much left to be done!" (Well, it didn't actually say that, but I'll bet it was thinking it.) So while the closing cutscene was a satisfying finale, the climactic build-up and framing left a lot to be desired.

Speaking of cutscenes, cinematic presentation is one area where RMI really feels like a "budget" title. After the simple introductory sequence (no shipwreck, sorry), there are virtually no cutscenes at all throughout the game. In fact, there are also no transitions between nodes, no interactive dialogues, and no character animations. Instead, key moments of the game are depicted with sketch drawings. While this is a functional alternative with some merit, the bottom line is that it's no substitute for a more visually compelling presentation. I'm reluctant to criticize any game for issues likely tied to financial constraints, but I am bound to point them out, and RMI does suffer somewhat for the omissions. Not enough to ruin or even tarnish the experience by any means, but enough to prevent it from reaching its full potential to stand among the genre's greats.

It's a rare pleasure to find a game that surpasses expectation, but Return to Mysterious Island is just such an accomplishment. Simply put, it's a game I suspect everyone will enjoy, regardless of personal preferences or experience. With modest ambitions, it succeeds in what it tries to be and forsakes what it knows it can't. It embraces the things we cherish about the genre, but innovates just enough to be truly fresh and new. It may not be splashy or epic or complex enough to make many Top 10 lists, but as it retails for a very affordable price, it’s great value for a few fun-filled evenings of adventuring goodness.

A much simpler formula this time... Combine money with game box on counter. Use on cashier. What do you get? Return to Mysterious Island. You are getting it, right?


Return to Mysterious Island is available at:

What our readers think of Return to Mysterious Island

Average
Readers rating

Good

3.5 stars out of 5
Average based on 15 ratings
Your rating
Log in or Register to post ratings.

Posted by Houie on Jan 1, 2014

Re-defines 1st person adventure stereotypes. Great game!

~8 hours Before I tried this game, I thought all 1st person adventure games were "Myst clones." This game completely changed my perspective on it. The puzzle mechanics of this game are awesome. For those who are fans of item collection and... Read the review »

Posted by emric on Jun 10, 2012

only for lovers of puzzle-centric, 1st-person solitary exploration style adventures

I'm really not into 1st person perspective adventures. but i got this game as part of a 5 game bundle that i bought, so i thought i might as well give it a go. initially i thought it was ok, so i'll start with the good stuff. the character design... Read the review »

review

Adventure games by Kheops Studio

Fall Trilogy (Series)
PC, Casual

Fall Trilogy (Series) 2011

In the previous two chapters, you woke up in a new place on a mission that was unrelated to the previous one. First you found yourself a temple explorer, and then became a secret agent in a sterile, hi-tech building, solving many enigmas that helped you get some of your memories back. This time you

» View all games in this series
Safecracker (Series)
DS

Safecracker (Series) 2009

The story develops around you being an expert safecracker, who is hired by the wealthy family of a recently deceased billionaire, to search for the last will and testament of their late relative, Duncan W. Adams. Being an avid safe collector and an “eccentric”, to say the least, Adams ha

» View all games in this series
Mysterious Island (Series)
PC, Mac

Mysterious Island (Series) 2009

The sequel begins with the crash of the helicopter that came to rescue Mina. She survived but is once again trapped on the island. All of a sudden, before her very eyes, an unknown disease afflicts the plants first, then the animal life. Mina explores the island to locate the source of the infection

» View all games in this series

Nostradamus: The Last Prophecy  2007

Nostradamus: The Last Prophecy transports players to 16th century Provence, in a country ravaged by religious wars and devastated by the plague. Despite the end of her rule as regent three years ago, Catherine de Médicis still holds the reins of power, making her the target of repeated attack...

Cleopatra: Riddle of the Tomb  2007

The country is divided by civil war pitting Cleopatra’s supporters against those of her brother and husband, Ptolemy, who is ravaging the country. In this climate of terror, Thomas, a young apprentice to Akkad, Cleopatra’s astrologist and astronomist, falls in love with his Master’...

The Secrets of Da Vinci: The Forbidden Manuscript  2006

Under the pretenses of studying Leonardo Da Vinci's machines and searching for his sketches, a young artist named Valdo is really in Da Vinci's former residence to find a mysterious codex for his unknown employer. You will come to learn about the many facets of Da Vinci's talents as you find yourse...

VOYAGE  2005

An ancient temple… mysterious ruins… a fascinating subterranean civilization… Live the dream that begins with the tale of three visionaries whose ideas revolve around pioneering new explorations to far off places of discovery. An epic adventure inspired by Jules Verne, Voyage ...

Secret of the Lost Cavern (Series)
PC, Mac

Secret of the Lost Cavern (Series) 2005

Venture across beautifully rugged landscapes and discover a primitive world through the eyes of Arok... but be sure to use your wits and keen awareness of the terrain to survive the vast wilderness.

» View all games in this series
Crystal Key (Series)
PC

Crystal Key (Series) 2004

Your quest for the Crystal Key will take you on another incredible adventure. Your intellect and intuition will be your greatest allies as you journey through breathtaking worlds filled with beauty, mystery and technological wonders. Embrace the challenge as you carefully examine and solve each pu

» View all games in this series
Egypt (Series)
PC, Mac

Egypt (Series) 2004

An ancient riddle lies waiting to be solved. Embark on an amazing journey as you attempt to uncover the hidden secrets behind a fascinating mystery. As your adventure unfolds, you must solve an array of ancient riddles that will help a dying Pharaoh survive and restore Egypt to glory.

» View all games in this series
Dracula (Series)
PC, Mac

Dracula (Series) 0

Mgr Arno Moriani, the “devil's advocate,” is carrying out a canonization process, investigating in the interwar years a potential candidate for beatification in Transylvania. His investigation is quickly wrapped up. The strange stigmata on the corpse are not the hallmark of some divine p

» View all games in this series

Destination: Treasure Island

Little does Jim know that he is about to embark on a new adventure. On this forbidding island, danger awaits Jim at every turn. Jim will have to overcome the tests and traps set by Long John Silver, hordes of pirates set on vengeance, and a much darker presence lurking in the forest. But this is ...