Phantasmagoria review

Phantasmagoria
Phantasmagoria
The Good:
  • Captivating musical score
  • Last acts of the game are engaging and atmospheric
  • Very powerful finale
  • An experiment that was really ahead of its time
The Bad:
  • Stereotypical plot and writing
  • Gameplay simplified to the point of being almost superfluous
  • Bad, unbelievable acting
Our Verdict: Phantasmagoria is deeply flawed, both in story and gameplay, but it was a bold experiment that spawned numerous followers, and even today manages to be frightening interactive movie in its own right.

Once upon a time, in the land of Serenia, a luxuriant green valley surrounded by azure mountains and covered by a pale sky, there was a shabby magical shop, run by a long-bearded wizard by the name of Crispin…

No, wait, that is the wrong game. This is an adventure from the pen of none other than Roberta Williams, but this time around you will do without Cedric the Owl, King Graham and the royal family of Daventry. And if you think that a Roberta Williams game automatically means an enjoyable trip through a colorful world, perfect for parents and children alike, you’re in for a very big surprise with Phantasmagoria. Williams had already shown herself eager to write dark and unsettling stories – her debut adventure, Mystery House, and The Colonel’s Bequest were clear signs – but with Phantasmagoria she totally raised the bar, deciding to shock players and grab them by the throat with a disturbing story about a lonely woman fighting powerful malevolent forces.

If the premise doesn’t sound shocking today, that is largely because of Phantasmagoria. The historical value of this game is indisputable, since it opened the way for a lengthy succession of games that borrowed heavily from its style, its graphical presentation, its storytelling gimmicks and more. Many of those games overtook Phantasmagoria both in quality and in success, because Roberta Williams’ sixteenth adventure is far from perfect. Nevertheless, without it we might never have experienced masterpieces like The Beast Within in the years to follow.

Phantasmagoria is a milestone in at least one other regard: nowadays it’s pretty common to talk about appealing to the casual market, but Roberta Williams did it first, with this very game. Phantasmagoria, for better or worse, put PC gaming on popular magazine covers and TV newscasts, creating unprecedented media coverage that convinced even many non-gamers to go out and buy the game. And the reactions back then were generally enthusiastic. Even Entertainment Weekly declared that the game was “one of the surest signs yet of computer games approaching the quality level of movies.”

What is so outstanding about the game, then? What magnificent qualities attracted the attention of serious journalists and gossip columnists alike? For the experienced adventure gamer, the answer is disappointing: there’s nothing so outstanding about the game, which is actually mediocre in terms of plot and unsatisfactory in terms of gameplay. The hype for such an average adventure was due to the scandal that caused a moralistic crusade by some concerned parents and stores which refused to sell the game.

Phantasmagoria casts the player in the role of Adrienne Delaney, an attractive thirty-something novelist with a handsome husband, Donald, and a fairy tale-like life. The happy couple has just rented an old, extravagant mansion in New England because Don, a renowned photographer, has chosen the wooded estate as the perfect place for his latest photo session. The only problem is that, during the 19th century, the mansion was home to an eccentric illusionist, Zoltan Carnovash, whose wives (he had four of them) had the inexplicable habit of mysteriously disappearing without any trace, and even now there are rumors in the nearby town that the house is cursed. Adrienne and Don knew nothing of this when they purchased the manor, but it took only a nightmare and some extremely vivid hallucinations for Adrienne to start realizing that something is very wrong with the place.

In fact, something terrible did happen in the mansion almost a century before, something as twisted and corrupted as Zoltan himself, whose haughty, flamboyant and petulant personality is embodied in every brick of his eccentric manor. Adrienne soon finds herself entangled in an old story of unfathomable secrets and dark magic, trying not only to save her husband’s soul but to solve the gruesome mystery buried underneath Carnovash Manor. What ancient evil did Zoltan awaken in his search for power? How many lives has he sacrificed for his ambition? The truth lies in a grim, eerie mausoleum, as well as in the memories of the only person still alive who had the chance to meet the old magician himself. Adrienne will have to unearth those secrets quickly, however, because Zoltan’s curse is affecting Don, and her only hope for his salvation may be a long-forgotten, perilous ritual.

As for that scandal, through the course of its seven acts, Phantasmagoria manages to show veiled bits of female nudity, sex scenes, gruesome deaths, tortures and abuses, splatter details of blood and bowels, and eventually a “rape” scene with a strong emotional involvement. It’s this last issue that stirred up outraged reactions which claimed that an explicit scene of domestic violence was not only dangerous but also immoral. The reality is that this infamous scene is one of the most poignant moments in the whole game. Whilst the haunted house plot is fairly superficial and stereotypical, the relationship between Adrienne and Don, who becomes perverted by the house’s malevolent influence, is wonderfully and even tactfully depicted. That particular scene helps to deepen the theme of their star-crossed love, showing the strength of Adrienne’s affection toward her husband even in the face of the twisted curse that is slowly destroying him. Unfortunately, this is pretty much a standalone case, since the other aspects of the plot and the writing feel utterly contrived. I think Roberta Williams felt more comfortable with the light-hearted, fairy tale atmosphere of King’s Quest, because her ventures into the darker corners of the human soul often show an overly heavy reliance on abused clichés, thus hampering the emotional impact of her horror and mystery stories.

Continued on the next page...


What our readers think of Phantasmagoria


Posted by Quazatron on Jun 13, 2013

Classic horror game


Phantasmagoria still is one of my favorite adventure games. Its story feels like a classic horror movie and presents the player a lot of scary moments and uncomfortable scenes. The ambience has a clear sense of gothic and the whole story reminds me of old...

review

Adventure games by Sierra On-Line

Gabriel Knight (Series)

Gabriel Knight (Series) 1999

Welcome to the remote French village of Rennes-le-Chateau.

» View all games in this series
Quest for Glory (Series)

Quest for Glory (Series) 1998

The Council of Silmaria has set before you the seven deadly Rites of Rulership.

» View all games in this series
Shivers (Series)

Shivers (Series) 1997

I’m convinced that someone or some thing is after me.

» View all games in this series
Phantasmagoria (Series)

Phantasmagoria (Series) 1996

Curtis Craig is a quiet young man.

» View all games in this series
Leisure Suit Larry (Series)

Leisure Suit Larry (Series) 1996

Will Larry hit bottom? Or dock his little dinghy? Drop a world-class lounge lizard onto a cruise ship filled with gorgeous women and what do you get? Side-splitting slapstick? A bawdy bevy of beauties? The Lust Boat?.

» View all games in this series

Lighthouse: The Dark Being  1996

Pass through a shimmering portal into a world teeming with invention, discovery.

Space Quest (Series)

Space Quest (Series) 1995

Fight grime and battle evil adversaries with Roger as he joins farces with video games, TV and sci-fi movies, past and present – in his wildest adventure ever.

» View all games in this series

Torin’s Passage  1995

I thought I had silenced them all.

King’s Quest (Series)

King’s Quest (Series) 1994

Princess Rosella is swept off to the lands of Eldritch by a magical whirlpool, after which her mother, Queen Valanice, jumps in to rescue her wayward daughter.

» View all games in this series
Sierra Discovery Series (Series)

Sierra Discovery Series (Series) 1993

Lost Secret of the Rainforest is a trek through lush jungles, mysterious caverns, and ancient ruins atop craccy, mist-covered peaks, requiring you to defeat real-life dangers threatening the rainforests of South America.

» View all games in this series
Police Quest (Series)

Police Quest (Series) 1993

Someone’s on a killing spree, and it’s up to you to solve a string of seemingly random murders.

» View all games in this series

Freddy Pharkas Frontier Pharmacist  1993

Return with us now to those thrilling days of yesteryear… when men were men, women were women, and sheep were scared! The year is 1888; the setting, post-Gold Rush California.

Pepper’s Adventures in Time  1993

Ride the wild time machine into American history with Pepper’s Adventures in Time! .

Laura Bow mysteries (Series)

Laura Bow mysteries (Series) 1992

Laura Bow, intrepid heroine of The Colonel’s Bequest, is back! This time she’s trapped in a huge, imposing museum in the dead of night, surrounded by socialites, miscreants, thieves… and a cold, relentless murderer.

» View all games in this series
Mixed-Up (Series)

Mixed-Up (Series) 1991

The mischievous Bookend has mixed up the pieces of five of the world’s most famous fairy tales.

» View all games in this series
Conquests (Series)

Conquests (Series) 1991

The gauntlet has been dropped.

» View all games in this series

Codename: ICEMAN  1989

Oil shortages, international politics and radical terrorists form the backdrop for a powerful story of world crisis, superpower conflict and high tech escapades.

Gold Rush! (Series)

Gold Rush! (Series) 1988

The gold rush is on! Sell your land, pack your bags, and grab the next ride out, because fortune lies just 2,500 miles away.

» View all games in this series

The Black Cauldron  1986

Find the Black Cauldron and defeat the forces of the wicked Horned King by destroying the cauldron’s magical powers, removing it forever as a threat to humankind.

» Full game details

The Dark Crystal  1983

In a faraway world, an event of cosmic importance is about to occur: a Great Conjunction of the planet’s Three Suns.

» Full game details

Mystery House  1980

As you near the front yard of the large, old Victorian house, you feel an unexplainable tension.