Broken Sword 2: The Smoking Mirror review

The Good:
  • The graphics are better than any cartoon you'll see this year. Good voice acting and decent background music
The Bad:
  • Puzzles and story mostly a waste of time
Our Verdict: All smoke and mirrors, and very little substance.

Broken Sword: The Smoking Mirror is Revolution Software's follow-up to the extraordinary graphic adventure Circle of Blood (called Broken Sword: The Shadow of the Templars in Europe). Like its predecessor, The Smoking Mirror is a visually beautiful game that puts its two central characters, American adventurer George Stobbart and his French reporter girlfriend Nico Collard, in pursuit of the truth behind an age-old myth. This time, the two reluctant adventurers must travel the world in a race to stop the return of Tezcatlipoca, the legendary Mayan God of Death.

Unfortunately, the similarities to the original all but end there.

Although the game begins on an exciting note—Nico is kidnapped, and George finds himself tied to a chair in a burning house—it quickly deteriorates into a series of brainless puzzles and mostly humorless gags. While Circle of Blood featured a sprawling story of mystery and wonder, offset by George's timely wit, The Smoking Mirror relies almost entirely on poor jokes to hide its somewhat thin plot.

In the first game, George provided the comic relief against a serious and intriguing backdrop; here, the backdrop itself tries for humor but instead falls flat. (The tribe of Central American Indians enamored with their recent discovery of underwear is just one of many unnecessary and distracting gags.)

Missing is the real sense of depth and intrigue that made the original so exciting, and gone too are the more challenging puzzles. While Circle of Blood was hardly an Einstein-level challenge, it was intricately plotted and thought provoking, and most puzzles required a degree of consideration before the answer became obvious. Not so with The Smoking Mirror. The majority of puzzles are painfully easy to the point where when I reached the endgame, I began to wonder if I’d somehow missed part of the story.

It's not all bad, of course. Like its predecessor, the graphics are impressive, as are the animated cut scenes that pop up as the story progresses. The ability to play as Nico in off-setting chapters is also a nice feature, and would have been a great way to drum up suspense with the cliffhanger endings if the game had been more intriguing as a whole.

Really, that's the heart of the problem: The most intriguing thing about The Smoking Mirror is how it could possibly have been created by the same folks who came up with its predecessor. If you're looking for a really great graphic adventure game, give Circle of Blood a try, but resist the temptation to pick up its sequel. Like the game's title implies, it’s all smoke and mirrors, and very little substance.

What our readers think of Broken Sword 2: The Smoking Mirror

Posted by thorn969 on May 19, 2014

Annoying... bad story... not a worthy sequel

The puzzles often felt like they were just put in for the sake of being puzzles rather than as part of the story in the original. The story mixed in too much fantasy with reality to hold the attention. And sometimes it seemed like you were wandering around...

Posted by Antrax on Oct 1, 2013

Awful, as advertised

This is definitely a Broken Sword title. It suffers from all the shortcomings of its predecessor, then heaps on new ones. There are three clashing graphic styles used throughout the game. The character portraits don't look like the character sprites don't...

Posted by Intense Degree on Aug 13, 2012
It must be said that this game isn't as good as the first, but it is still a great game. To be fair, the first is among the contenders for the best game ever so matching it was going to be tricky. Voice acting is once again great, graphics are lovely sound...


Adventure games by Revolution

Happiless  2018

As a feline detective, who helped reunite some alcoholics with their families not long ago, you must get inside the minds of the United Kingdom dwellers to investigate the scariest crime on Sadmir planet – the kidnapping of highly respected professor Cookie, a PhD in caramel science.

» Full game details
Broken Sword (Series)

Broken Sword (Series) 2014

When a mysterious painting is stolen during an armed raid on a Paris gallery, George and Nico are thrown by chance into the investigation together.

» View all games in this series
Beneath a Steel Sky (Series)

Beneath a Steel Sky (Series) 2009

When orphaned Robert Foster is seized at gunpoint from the peaceful village he calls home and flown a thousand miles to a city he's never seen, he can only ask himself: why me? Escaping from his abductors into the dark metropolis, he vows to avenge the murder of the only family he's ever known.

» View all games in this series

Gold and Glory: The Road to El Dorado  2000

Join Tulia and Miguel in their thrilling adventure to El Dorado, the legendary lost city of gold.

Lure of the Temptress  1991

Slowly, you open your eyes in the dim light and begin to take in your surroundings.