03-23-2005, 01:34 PM | #1 |
Doctor Watson
Join Date: Sep 2003
Location: The Catacombs
Posts: 4,736
|
Today I understood that puzzles matter
This post will spoil the games Grim Fandango and Cirque de Zale.
Puzzles in amateur games suck. The main problem is not that too many puzzles are of the I-give-you-the-scissors-so-you'll-give-me-the-electronic-monkey -variety. It is only a part of the problem. The real problem is that those puzzles just don't fit in the plot. At all. Let me compare Grim Fandango with Cirque de Zale. In Grim Fandango there's a puzzle in which you need to help the Lost Souls Alliance by getting them a replica of Manny's teeth and a few pigeon eggs. In return the leader of the LSA will let Manny continue his quest. The LSA has already played and will play a major part in the later development of the plot, and you solving the puzzle has a real meaning in the development of the story. In Cirque de Zale there's a puzzle in which you need to give a basket of goodies to a random pimp. In return the pimp will... I don't remember what it was, but I'm sure it wasn't that necessary or important. She'll help you somehow. There is no difference in the basic structure of those puzzles. However, the pimp is just a random person thrown out to the streets. After the first encounter you will never see her again. The pimp doesn't tell you anything that would help you with the game later on, and it isn't really an integral part of the plot. Another example is from the award-winning game Apprentice II. None of the puzzles actually are a part of the story. In fact, you solve a number of puzzles that have nothing to do with the plot in order to make the plot progress. The game can be fun, but it's not very good game design. Simply put, we have to get rid of making these parody adventure games. Apprentice II was otherwise very good and well developed as a game, but its puzzles has very little to do with the plot itself. What do you think? P.S. I've previously posted this at Adventure Developers.
__________________
Don't worry, I'm a doctor. |
03-23-2005, 04:35 PM | #2 |
Dungeon Master
Join Date: Nov 2003
Location: Poland
Posts: 4,152
|
I agree. Another irritating thing is when designers expect me to switch from kid who needs guidance ("No, I'll take [put a name of the object here]" says character "only if I have a really good reason for it") to an omniscient being mode in a matter of seconds. Bunny slippers puzzle from Two of a Kind comes to mind, although this problem is just as common in commercial games as well.
__________________
What's happening? Wh... Where am I? |
03-23-2005, 05:40 PM | #3 |
El Luchador
|
I couldn't agree more.
Of course, the biggest reason I don't play amateur adventures is the terrible story that most of them have. There happen to be a few goldies, but like you say, most of them feature very typical non-plot driven puzzles.
__________________
Use Verb On Noun - Adventure game inspired illustrations |
03-26-2005, 05:51 PM | #4 |
Old Git
Join Date: Feb 2005
Location: Arlington, VA
Posts: 113
|
I agree completely. I've just played Apprentice II and Grim Fandango and found that I needed to consult a walkthough with AP II for almost every puzzle but didn't need to much with GF. I don't think the GF ones were much easier, it's just that they were more integrated so you got more hints about what you should do.
Still, at least we get a good reminder about why the best things in the world usually aren't free! Andy.
__________________
I'm not really here - it's just your warped imagination. |
03-26-2005, 07:25 PM | #5 |
Liver of Life
Join Date: Sep 2003
Posts: 1,317
|
I too agree. Many amateur adventure game puzzles seem just like obstacles to your continuing the game. "You do this and you can keep playing. Period."
|
03-26-2005, 11:47 PM | #6 |
Citizen of Bizarro World
Join Date: Mar 2004
Location: Htrae
Posts: 4,219
|
I three agree! Somewhat. I enjoyed Cirque de Zale, especially the main character. It didn't have much of a story, but the puzzles did (sort of) tie into it, because most of the puzzles involved helping people so they'd join your troupe (and gathering the troupe is basically the story ). But I didn't much care about his troupe or gathering them, so that must be why those puzzles had such little impact on you or me. Actually, what bothered me more was the fact that they were so easy! I usually don't feel an adventure game is successful if it doesn't at least once lead me to the guilty pleasure of peeking into a walkthrough.
__________________
By no rocket’s blue shade am no shells dead down there, Gave no proof all day long that the flag was unwhere! No say does am spar-strangled shroud hang limply! Under land of no free! Am us home coward-leeee! ~Excerpt from the Bizarro Anthem |
03-27-2005, 03:02 AM | #7 |
False Hope
Join Date: Apr 2004
Posts: 42
|
The obstacle-puzzle is somewhat common in all adventures, not just UG ones, I think. For example in Moment Of Silence you have to get your colleague some food - and there's a puzzle which is the first thing in that game which felt like a puzzle.
However there still are games like Full Throttle. I read somewhere that Tim Schaffer didn't want to ruin the fast pacing of the game by adding obstacles. So as a result, the game got severely shortened. |
03-27-2005, 10:42 AM | #8 | ||||
Elegantly copy+pasted
Join Date: Jan 2005
Posts: 1,773
|
Quote:
I therefore think the puzzle was quite well integrated in the plot. I'm not a big fan of the puzzles in the game, since most of the time you're just carrying objects from one screen to another, but that's a problem with the nature of the puzzles much more than how they fit into the story. Quote:
Anyway, Ian Schlaepfer acknowledged this concern in the interview for the 20004 TCN Awards: Quote:
Quote:
__________________
Please excuse me. I've got to see a man about a dog. |
||||
03-27-2005, 11:20 AM | #9 |
Senior Member
Join Date: Sep 2003
Posts: 1,117
|
I disagree.
Actually, I agree, I just thought this thread could use some variety. |
03-27-2005, 02:21 PM | #10 | |
Doctor Watson
Join Date: Sep 2003
Location: The Catacombs
Posts: 4,736
|
Quote:
__________________
Don't worry, I'm a doctor. |
|
03-27-2005, 02:28 PM | #11 | ||
Doctor Watson
Join Date: Sep 2003
Location: The Catacombs
Posts: 4,736
|
Quote:
Quote:
__________________
Don't worry, I'm a doctor. |
||
03-27-2005, 02:39 PM | #12 |
Doctor Watson
Join Date: Sep 2003
Location: The Catacombs
Posts: 4,736
|
Also, I think puzzles should gradually teach you more about the game world and the plot and the characters. This does not happen in games like Apprentice II and Cirque de Zale. There's a very fixed goal with no surprises.
__________________
Don't worry, I'm a doctor. |
03-27-2005, 03:02 PM | #13 |
merely human
Join Date: Sep 2003
Location: Chicago
Posts: 22,309
|
Maybe it's just that many adventure games, commercial and underground, merely blindly follow the conventions without ever actually examining them very closely, critically, and constructively.
All too often it looks like this: story > puzzle > story > puzzle > story... There doesn't seem to be an organic structure to these games, if you know what I mean. They don't seem to follow a particular cohesiveness and even chaos, that we are accustomed to when we step out our front doors. And so they end up not only lacking cohesion, but also dimension. I feel like the games take me by the hand and lead me from point A to B, no questions asked. The elements in the games - character, details, narrative expositions, items - have nothing to do with each other and exist for the sole purpose of waiting for you to click on them. I've played only a few underground games, and mostly forgot about them. But it seems that they merely mimic what many commercial games do, and what they do is mimic as well. Which imparts a feeling of sheer drone mechanics, and the world never cracks open for me. I feel like I'm just.....playing a game.
__________________
platform: laptop, iPhone 3Gs | gaming: x360, PS3, psp, iPhone, wii | blog: a space alien | book: the moral landscape: how science can determine human values by sam harris | games: l.a.noire, portal 2, brink, dragon age 2, heavy rain | sites: NPR, skeptoid, gaygamer | music: ray lamontagne, adele, washed out, james blake | twitter: a_space_alien |
03-27-2005, 03:03 PM | #14 |
Member
Join Date: Jun 2004
Posts: 71
|
I played Cirque de Zale and thought that some of the "bad approach" might've been done on purpose because the whole game is pretty much a parody on adventure games and tries to "defy" and "expose" its flaws. So, I'm not sure if the "pimp puzzle" was done on purpose to be bad or not. However, I didn't like the game anyway for different reasons. A lot of stuff just wasn't funny. It seemed to try too hard to be a parody, so that pretty much every step was an attempt to ridicule some adventure game "flaws". I would definitely enjoy an occasional "expose the flaw" joke in a normal adventure game but when it's all it's built on, the game becomes boring. Some of the "jokes" just seemed extremely lame too, sorry to say. But hey, no one said it was easy to be funny or make a good game. No game is perfect, and I hope the designer's next one will be a bit less of a parody and more of an exciting adventure.
|
03-29-2005, 05:02 AM | #15 |
Old Git
Join Date: Feb 2005
Location: Arlington, VA
Posts: 113
|
I was thinking about this last night and realized two things:
a) I might have come across as being too negative about amateur games (Apprentice in particular). I want to state that I have nothing but admiration for the folks that devote so much time, energy and love into these wonderful games. I had a blast playing both Apprentice games and will download AP III the moment it is released. To compare one of the best amateur games with, arguably, the best professional adventure game ever released (Grim Fandango) is a little unfair! b) The title of this thread is really wrong! What it really should say is "Today I understood that story matters". Because what we're really saying is that what many amateur adventures lack is true story. If you start from the story you can add the puzzles in so they fit. If you start from the puzzles you end up with, well, the puzzles. Andy.
__________________
I'm not really here - it's just your warped imagination. |
03-29-2005, 06:15 AM | #16 | |
Doctor Watson
Join Date: Sep 2003
Location: The Catacombs
Posts: 4,736
|
Quote:
However, I still think the problem is that the creators start with the story. Then they add puzzles that addvance the story, but not in small enough segments, but big chunks. The puzzles should tell the story. That's what I meant about puzzles mattering. You can have a very good story, but only tell it through cutscenes, and in between cutscenes the player is occupied by little side quests (learning more about Centaur Races, for example). It is unfair to compare Apprentice II and Grim Fandango, but amateur games will always stay bad if nobody is willing to criticise them and say "that is not good enough".
__________________
Don't worry, I'm a doctor. |
|
03-29-2005, 10:07 AM | #17 | |
The Thread™ will die.
|
Quote:
Ignoring this, though, I would never personally advocate basing a storyline around puzzles in preference to writing the story first. By all means modify the storyline to allow puzzles to come out of it, but the story is what one is here to tell. |
|
03-29-2005, 10:35 AM | #18 | |
Doctor Watson
Join Date: Sep 2003
Location: The Catacombs
Posts: 4,736
|
Quote:
"Puzzles evolve organically out of that, or at least they should if the game is any good" is kinda what I meant. My approach is still that there has to be a reason to tell the story as a game. I try to think about that consciously, and even put some kind of deeper idea into the solution of the puzzle so that the playing experience would be coherent. The reason is the puzzles - how they enhance the story.
__________________
Don't worry, I'm a doctor. Last edited by Wormsie; 03-29-2005 at 10:43 AM. |
|
03-29-2005, 10:39 AM | #19 | |
The Thread™ will die.
|
Quote:
|
|
03-29-2005, 10:44 AM | #20 | |
Dungeon Master
Join Date: Nov 2003
Location: Poland
Posts: 4,152
|
Quote:
__________________
What's happening? Wh... Where am I? |
|
|