[rtrooney]

The game I replayed the most was Shivers. Must have replayed it at least seven times. Mostly because I enjoyed it. But also because there were multiple ways of playing it, e.g., high score, low score, etc.. Plus the fact that I and a few others were involved in what would now be called a "viral marketing campaign" on the old CompuServe GAMERS forum didn't hurt either.

[Obscurista]

Laura Bow II! I used to replay that one just for the music (I'd even bounce around my apartment to it.. hehe.. that was back in my college days when I used to multi-task between adventure games, IRC chatting, and schoolwork into the wee hours of the morning *sigh*). The crazy dialogue didn't diminish in appeal with repeated reads/listens, either! (I found a few easter eggs along the way, too, which made it all the more fun. )

Also KQ 2-6, mostly five and six.

[crabapple]

Myst.
Especially if you count all the versions on different platforms.

Shivers 1 would be my second most replayed.

[[ben]]

Not sure actually, but I seldom replay anything. So the adventure games I've replayed are few and I believe the ones I've played three times each is Monkey Island 3 and Hand Fate. HoF is not a fantastic adventure game, but I just love its atmosphere.

However I've watched a few longplays on youtube of some games that I have fond memories of. I watched through Grim Fandango, The Dig and Full Throttle.

[Twizman]

Same as zobrak: Sam & Max Hit the Road.

Dialogue is great and keeps giving. I like the wacky characters.


Day of the Tentacle a close second.

[Datadog]

Lost count, but I still replay KQ6 and DOTT on a yearly basis. All the other classics from Sierra and LucasArts I've probably replayed dozens of times as a kid (ESPECIALLY the Monkey Island games).

[Bastich]

I rarely ever replay games of any genre and if I do, it's usually about 5-10 years after the 1st playthrough.

Played Twice:
Sanitarium
Longest Journey
Broken Sword
Mean Streets
Under a Killing Moon
Pandora Directive
Blade Runner (to multiple endings on each occasion)
Dark Seed
Elvira: Mistress of the Dark
Future Wars
Rise of the Dragon

There might be a couple more, but that's what I can think of off-hand.

The game I've played the most though is Hitchhiker's Guide to the Galaxy. I don't know how many times but definitely at least 5 times. All but once was in the 80s though. I replayed it the last time probably 8-10 years ago.

[mbday630]

I have played Gabriel Knight 1 probably at least 50 times. I keep replaying that one because sometimes I get an extra point from the highest score, but I don't know what causes the extra point, so I keep trying to figure it out. I have played GK2 at least 10 times. Gk3 I have played around 5 times.

I have played Simon the Sorcerer 1 at least 30 times. I have played Simon the Sorcerer 2 at least 15 times. I have played Day of the Tentacle probably around 40 to 50 times. Broken Sword games, 1 and 2, I have played probably 10-15 times each. Lost Horizon I played around 5 times. Book of Unwritten Tales I played at least 5 times.

Edna and Harvey I have played 4 or 5 times. Torins Passage I have played around 15-20 times The Monkey Island games I have played probably 20 times for each one. Lands of Lore 1, probably around 20 times.

My games are like old friends to me and I like to visit them often. even though I know all the the puzzles, it is just fun for me to do it again. I am sure there are several more that I have played over and over, but these are the ones that I can think of right now.

[TimovieMan]

Originally Posted by mbday630

I have played Gabriel Knight 1 probably at least 50 times. I keep replaying that one because sometimes I get an extra point from the highest score, but I don't know what causes the extra point, so I keep trying to figure it out. I have played GK2 at least 10 times. Gk3 I have played around 5 times.

I have played Simon the Sorcerer 1 at least 30 times. I have played Simon the Sorcerer 2 at least 15 times. I have played Day of the Tentacle probably around 40 to 50 times. Broken Sword games, 1 and 2, I have played probably 10-15 times each. Lost Horizon I played around 5 times. Book of Unwritten Tales I played at least 5 times.

Edna and Harvey I have played 4 or 5 times. Torins Passage I have played around 15-20 times The Monkey Island games I have played probably 20 times for each one. Lands of Lore 1, probably around 20 times.

[adventurefan]

I've probably replayed the first 3 Monkey Island games the most, but even then, I think I've only played each through about 2-3 times.

[zane]

Iv played through gabriel knight: SotF about 8 or 9 times. Iv played it so much that iv played drinking games with it (1 drink per 1 point ) My record is somewhere around 200 points in a night.
EDIT: also, i tried playing the same game with a tex murphy game once. And quickly realized it was a terrible terrible idea.

[dazsin]

I have probably replayed Broken Sword about 6 times.

Follwed by more than twice for the first 3 Monkey Islands, and Simon the Sorcerer 1 and 2

[Manhunter71]

For me, best replayability value has to be the Gabriel Knight series - all of them. The level of historical detail and fact put into these games is just amazing.
Also, The Longest Journey - possibly one of the greatest games of all time.

Others worth mentioning - Black Dahlia, but very hard to get working properly on modern pcs.
And of course the first few Monkey Island games

Ohh man! How could I forget Broken Sword 1 and 2?? They nearly rate with the GK games for me

[DustyShinigami]

I've replayed the first two Broken Sword and Simon the Sorcerer games the most that I've lost count. It's gotta be over 15-20 times surely!

Trouble is, I've never bothered to count the amount of times I replay a game. I just play it.

Other games I've replayed the most would be Gabriel Knight 1-3, Monkey Island 1-3, and The Longest Journey. I think they're the only ones...