To be honest, Tim has the advantage of never having done any sequels (well, except for Monkey Island 2 of course, but that's more Ron's game). So he showed again and again that he is capable of coming up with new and exciting fantastical worlds. Maybe there is a feeling, especially shared by people who didn't play or didn't like Gray Matter, that Jane is only capable of doing Gabriel Knight or at least at her best while doing it.
It's an unfounded feeling, I agree, but I think that might be an unspoken emotional argument shared by quite a few.
|
