What you folks need (or what ANY community playthrough needs, for that matter) is a dedicated game master/mistress who loves some game and is ready to play ball and one good player (the more the better). The rest will follow.
Here, see how it's done.
I just browsed that whole thread and my heart was filled with joy once again.
Those were the days...
Yeah, I know I said nothing new, but people tend to easily forget simple truths so simple truths need to be repeated every now and then.