[cbman]

Very little replay value for me. I'm always baffled to read people say they've played Loom 20 times or whatever. I play them once only, although I will sometimes go through parts of a game again immediately after finishing it to get screenshots. But once the game has been 'put away' and uninstalled I will never play it again, just maybe enjoy the screenshots from time to time for my favourite games.

For me, it's no longer exciting once I know what's around the corner and redoing the same puzzles again or trawling through all the same dialogue again is just a chore. Sure, the moment you first hit on a solution it's satisfying, but doing the same thing again is just mechanial. That thrill can only be recaptured by overcoming new problems in new games.