After beating Secret Files, I can't say it's better than Nibiru. It's better in some aspects but worse in others.
For one, the puzzles (which is a big reason I play adventure games) were way better in Nibiru. Secret Files rarely had any (and I don't count putting items together and using them as puzzles) and the very few (like two or three) the game did have were very unoriginal and simple.
Sure, Nibiru had some absurd, illogical parts but Secret Files had them constantly. Most of the game is spent trying every single possibilty with every single item because anything is possible. Almost every single time I figured something out it was due to trial and error and not by thinking logically about what I should try to do next.
The only thing that was really better about Secret Files was the graphics and acting.
Hopefully the sequel will have better (and more plentiful) puzzles and hopefully it'll be a little more logical too.
|