Myst - I liked the game but I had no idea what to do at all for anything. The game seemed like it was completely mind-blowingly impossible to my young mind.
Bioshock - The graphics were good and I did love the setting, but it got boring to me fast, especially when I'd recently played Half Life 2, arguably the greatest game ever made. I bought a new graphics card to play the game and now I lost all interest. Maybe I overhyped it.
Metroid Prime: Corruption/Super Mario Galaxy - I loved this, but Brawl came out before I could beat it, so other Wii games were ignored. Also I never make the effort to unplug my DVD player to play Wii anymore. I love my Wii and it's sitting there so lonely
.
Tomb Raider: Any - I like shooting stuff but I don't like searching for pully switches. Cheat codes FTW!
Broken Sword 3 - This depresses me because I was really liking it and I can't get it to work on my PC.
I fail to finish so many games, it's sad.