I'm with you, Andrea. I found Culpa Innata to be so much wasted potential. I forced myself to finish the game, but my heart went out of it along the way, right around the puzzle where you had to
Spoiler:make hot wax out of microwaved lemonade to glue together a jigsaw puzzle that had nothing to do with anything.
All the praise for the game has left me suspicious, but maybe it's an Emperor's New Clothes kinda thing.