Whoops, I haven't been following this thread lately. Just FYI, for those questioning Gray Matter's ranking, a new update will be done shortly and the game
will be dropping.
The reasons it held #1 for so long are twofold: first, as some have suggested, I believe it would likely still top any fan poll of most-anticipated games, regardless of updates, and secondly, there just aren't any other games doing much better. At least, nothing that strikes me as deserving of the top spot.
That said, I'm gonna shake things up a bit momentarily.