Wow, I compiled a list in Excel a couple of days ago and completely forgot about it. Here's the most accurate ranking of my tastes I could come up with, then. I only took into consideration the (originally) commercial games I had completed:
- Grim Fandango
- Gabriel Knight
- Gabriel Knight 3
- Bad Mojo | Broken Sword | Death Gate | Longest Journey | Monkey Island 2: LeChuck's Revenge | Myst III: Exile | Riddle of Master Lu | Sanitarium | Voyage | Zork Grand Inquisitor
- Loom
- Shannara
- Spycraft
- Tex Murphy: Overseer
- Toonstruck
- Hitchhiker's Guide to the Galaxy
- Fahrenheit
- Space Quest 1
- Secret of Monkey Island
- Escape from Monkey Island
- Black Mirror
- Sherlock Holmes: Case of the Silver Earring
- Dark Eye
- Blade Runner
- Dracula - Resurrection
- Broken Sword 3
- Orion Burger
- Prisoner of Ice
- Neverhood
- Gabriel Knight 2
- Atlantis
- Curse of Monkey Island
- Echo: Secrets of the Lost Cavern
- Faust
- Indiana Jones and the Fate of Atlantis
- Beneath a Steel Sky
- Journeyman Project Turbo
- Leisure Suit Larry 7
- Feeble Files
- Broken Sword 2
- Moment of Silence | Runaway
- Atlantis 2 (aka Beyond Atlantis)
- Ace Ventura
- King's Quest 1
- King's Quest 2
- Leisure Suit Larry 3
- Książę i Tchórz (aka "Galador: Curse of Prince"/"The Prince and the Coward", but to the best of my knowledge it was only released in Polish and German, so I'm reluctant to refer to it with an English title)
- Simon the Sorcerer 2
- Indiana Jones and the Last Crusade
- Gilbert Goodmate
- Jack Orlando | Pilgrim | Pompeii | Post Mortem | Torin's Passage
- Thorgal: Odin's Quest (aka Curse of Atlantis: Thorgal's Quest)
- Jazz and Faust
